Destination governance in times of crisis and the role of public-private partnerships in tourism recovery from Covid-19: The case of Macao
Introduction
The coronavirus disease (COVID-19) which was declared a global pandemic by the World Health Organization (WHO) on 12 March 2020 has brought significant social, economic, and environmental costs globally. Among all industries, the tourism industry is one of the most severely impacted. As the pandemic spread, many countries and cities closed their borders. In 2020, international tourism arrivals declined by 93 percent compared with 2019 (Tourism International, 2021). The pandemic also brought significant changes in consumers’ requirements and behaviors, posing great challenges to tourism destination managers and tourism business operators (Sigala, 2020).
To recover from the crisis, an effective and a responsive mode of governance has been required (Neupane, 2021; Vargas, 2020). Governance concerns how societies are governed (Pierre & Peters, 2005). It is generally referred to as “all patterns of power, authority and rule that can secure order, and it is relevant to situations where there is a hierarchical state, where the state depends on others, or where the state plays little or no role” (Wan & Bramwell, 2015, p. 316). Accordingly, an effective and responsive mode of governance is needed to secure order, especially in times of crisis such as COVID-19. Ordinarily, governments tend to rely on traditional bureaucratic command and control mechanisms to govern tourism (Valente et al., 2015). However, conventional types of governance may be outmoded and inadequate in the context of sudden and severe crises such as pandemics. Thus, effective and responsive governance for tourism crisis management requires a government to shift its role from a steerer to that of an enabler in order to facilitate stakeholder collaboration toward common goals (Pierre & Peters, 2005). This is especially crucial for the tourism industry, given its highly interdependent nature (Paraskevas et al., 2013). The urgency and importance of establishing public-private partnerships during the pandemic was recently underscored by the United Nations World Tourism Organization (UNWTO) in its 2020 “Global Guidelines to Restart Tourism” report (UNWTO, 2020).
Prior studies underscore the crucial role played by governments (Pierre & Peters, 2005; Vargas, 2020). For example, during a pandemic, the government is the key player to address major challenging issues, such as establishing isolation measures, hygiene requirements, and ongoing support for tourism businesses. Some studies also point out the important roles played by the city's leader, whose leadership style and methods can significantly affect the recovery of the tourism sector (Mitroff, 2004; Wardman, 2020). At the same time, governments need to facilitate public-private partnerships to ensure different sectors fully understand and cooperate with new government requirements and to assist in offering new and innovative tourism products to accommodate market changes (Lai & Wong, 2020). It is therefore necessary for research to address not only the role of government in times of crisis such as the COVID pandemic, but also how it can forge networks of effective partnerships between public and private stakeholders in times of crisis, and how tourism-reliant communities, policymakers, and industry can work together via shared roles and formulate strategies for recovery.
Macao is selected as a case study to understand how public and private sectors partnered to spur the recovery of the tourism industry from COVID-19. Macao's heavy reliance on the tourism and casino gaming sectors rendered it economically vulnerable during the pandemic. Although as of August 2021 Macao had accumulated only 60 COVID cases and no deaths, travel restrictions caused visitor numbers to drop from 39.4 million in 2019 to 5.9 million in 2020 (Macao Statistics and Census Service, 2021). Although various regions and states implemented different types and levels of stringent policies and measures to control the COVID-19 pandemic (Hale et al., 2021), not all governments enjoyed the full support and cooperation of different sectors in society (Jørgensen et al., 2021). Macao's contrasting experience is remarkable, government and tourism business operators having engaged collaboratively in a rare demonstration of public-private partnership, resulting in later improvements in visitor numbers and revenues (Liu et al., 2021). It is therefore worthwhile to investigate the experience of Macao in adopting and pursuing a public-private partnership approach to recover from the pandemic.
The resilience and recovery of tourism destinations via effective governance appears to be seriously understudied. For example, many studies relating to COVID-19 and tourism are confined to how the hospitality sectors and governments responded to the crisis (Lai & Wong, 2020; Loi et al., 2021) or the impact of the pandemic on cities’ hospitality and tourism industry (Lim & To, 2021; Liu et al., 2021). Also, despite the increasing number of studies on COVID-19 and tourism, few have applied theories or perspectives of governance and the role of public-private partnerships in their study framework. Sigala (2020) advocates the need to adopt relevant perspectives to approach tourism in the post-COVID era:
COVID-19 tourism research should not only be the means to overcome the crisis and resume previously charted economic growth trajectories. It should lead to the refocusing, repurposing, reframing and reinterpretation of research questions, methodologies and outcomes, so that tourism stakeholders can in turn redirect their actioning, conduct and evolution. To that end, COVID-19 tourism research will be benefited by embedding, adapting, reflecting and expanding the theoretical lenses and perspectives of a much greater plurality of disciplines and constructs to guide and implement research (Sigala, 2020, p. 314).
Building on the perspective of governance and the literature on public-private partnerships and tourism crisis management, the current study examines the governance of Macao in its tourism recovery from the crisis. In particular, this research has three aims:
- (1)
To investigate the roles and strategies adopted by the Macao government (particularly the city's leader) in tourism industry recovery.
- (2)
To shed light on how the Macao government has forged an effective network of partnerships between public and private stakeholders in times of exceptional crisis such as COVID-19.
- (3)
To explore how a public-private partnership governance approach can be effectively applied in tourism recovery efforts.
Section snippets
Governance and public-private partnerships
Governance concerns how societies are governed and ruled (Pierre & Peters, 2005). Due to increasingly complicated social and political circumstances like rising community aspirations for democracy, deregulation and marketization, economic recession, globalization, global calls for sustainable development, and crises and disasters, governments are no longer able to steer alone (Bramwell & Lane, 2011). Governance signifies a new way of governing and refers to the collaboration of different
Methodology
This study adopted a qualitative face-to-face research approach. A qualitative approach is considered suitable because this study is exploratory in nature and, through in-depth interviews, interviewees can express their insights and experiences more openly and freely (Miles et al., 2014). Semi-structured interview questions were developed based on the literature covering governance, public-private partnerships, and tourism crisis management and recovery (Graci, 2013; Mitroff, 2004; Sigala, 2020
Impacts of COVID-19 on Macao's tourism
As Macao is heavily reliant on tourism, COVID-19 “hit the city's tourism industry hard” (Interviewee 5). An interviewee from the government said: “The pandemic is the most unpredictable crisis that Macao has ever faced. Unlike typhoons or earthquakes that we can predict how long they last for, this time the effects are long and unpredictable” (Interviewee 1). The pandemic brought many negative impacts to the industry. One interviewee said: “For a long period of time, all tourism businesses had
Discussion
The COVID-19 outbreak triggered Macao's tourism stakeholders to respond by creating a PPP form of governance. However, PPPs do not always guarantee success due to inconsistent expectations and contributions among different parties. In this study, the collaboration achieved between the public and private tourism sectors in Macao illustrates one way to combat COVID-19 and recover from it. Yet the success of this partnership is due not only to its close-knit development and step-by-step approach,
Funding
The research is funded by Macao Institute for Tourism Studies (IFTM) under proposal 236/DP/2020 and supported by the IFTM Tourism Research Centre (ITRC).
Declaration of competing interest
All authors declare they have no conflict of interest.
References (36)
- et al.
Crisis knowledge in tourism: Types, flows and governance
Annals of Tourism Research
(2013) - et al.
Developing an evolutionary tourism partnership model
Annals of Tourism Research
(1995) Tourism and COVID-19: Impacts and implications for advancing and resetting industry and research
Journal of Business Research
(2020)Challenges of sustainable tourism development in the developing world: The case of Turkey
Tourism Management
(2001)- et al.
Leadership and governance in regional tourism
Journal of Destination Marketing & Management
(2015) - et al.
Political economy and the emergence of a hybrid mode of governance of tourism planning
Tourism Management
(2015) - et al.
Critical research on the governance of tourism and sustainability
Journal of Sustainable Tourism
(2011) - et al.
Crisis leadership during and following COVID-19
Canadian Association of Radiologists Journal
(2020) Collaboration and partnership development for sustainable tourism
Tourism Geographies
(2013)- et al.
A global panel database of pandemic policies (Oxford COVID-19 Government Response Tracker)
Nature Human Behaviour
(2021)
Public support for government responses against COVID-19: Assessing levels and predictors in eight western democracies during 2020
West European Politics
Impact of the COVID-19 in tourism industry in Nepal and policy recommendation
Journal of Tourism & Adventure
Tourism organizations' responses to the COVID-19 pandemic: An investigation of the lockdown period
Current Issues in Tourism
Comparing crisis management practices in the hotel industry between initial and pandemic stages of COVID-19
International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management
Challenges and threats to traditional associations
The economic impact of a global pandemic on the tourism economy: The case of COVID-19 and Macao's destination- and gambling dependent economy
Current Issues in Tourism
Taking a break is for accomplishing a longer journey: Hospitality industry in Macao under the COVID-19 pandemic
International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management
Understanding the reactions of government and gaming concessionaires on COVID-19 through the neo-institutional theory – the case of Macao
International Journal of Hospitality Management
Cited by (33)
Why do negative career shocks foster perceived employability and career performance: A career crafting explanation
2024, International Journal of Hospitality ManagementResilience and recovery: A systematic review of tourism governance strategies in disaster-affected regions
2024, International Journal of Disaster Risk ReductionSustainable cooperation in the watershed ecological compensation public-private partnership project: Lessons from China's Chishui river basin
2023, Socio-Economic Planning SciencesAnalysis of collaborative urban public crisis governance in complex system: A multi-agent stochastic evolutionary game approach
2023, Sustainable Cities and Society