Harmoniously Denied: COVID-19 and the Latent Effects of Censorship
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
While few would doubt that censorship is a form of surveillance, the practice and theory of censorship does not hold as prominent a place within surveillance studies as one might think. In this paper, we demonstrate the constitutive effects of censorship that seep into the collective mentality and, in Foucauldian terms, “conducts the conduct.” We examine the wider socio-political impact of China’s censorship of COVID-19. We argue that censorship is a force “at large.” By this we refer to the pervasive uptake of censorship practices at different levels and how censorship manifests itself as a form of power unchained, making it difficult, if not impossible, to track and contain its impact, even for the authorities. We argue that censorship surveils the expressed and, by extension, regulates the not-yet-expressed. It surveils what can be perceived and, by extension, pre-conditions the not-yet-conceived. We highlight the domestic impact of how China’s censorship regime bends its population into acquiescing to a harmonious denial of its collective prospects and how it curtails the global response.
Article Details
Surveillance & Society uses a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 License.
- The author. The author licenses the article to the Surveillance Studies Network (SSN) for inclusion in Surveillance & Society (S&S), right of first publication. The copyright to the article remains with the author and any subsequent commercial reuse must be agreed by both parties.
- Non-commercial Users. SSN authorises all persons to use material published in S&S in any manner that is not primarily intended for or directed to commerical advantage or private monetary compensation, also provided that it is not modified and retains all attribution notices.
- Commercial Users. SSN retains the right to benefit from commerical reuse, in each specific case subject to the agreement of the author, and payment to SSN of a standard per-page fee (set by a vote of the Network and Editorial Board) by the Commercial User.
- Surveillance & Society supports open access archives and the free distribution of the results of academic work. Authors are encouraged to place copies of the final published version of their article in their university and / or other open access archives. We only ask that you make sure to include a link to the original published version on the Surveillance & Society website.
References
Althusser, Louis. (1971) 2008. On Ideology. London: Verso Books.
An, Delie. 2020. Why Xi Jinping’s Speech Sparkled Shocking Rise of Numbers in COVID Death and Confirm Cases. Radio France Internationale, January 22. http://www.rfi.fr/cn/中国/20200122-为什么习近平发话后武汉肺炎确诊及死亡人数恐怖攀升 [accessed May 28, 2020].
Andrejevic, Mark. 2005. The Work of Watching One Another: Lateral Surveillance, Risk, and Governance. Surveillance & Society 2 (4): 479–497.
———. 2006. The Discipline of Watching: Detection, Risk, and Lateral Surveillance. Critical Studies in Media Communication 23 (5): 391–407.
Apuzzo, Matt, and David Kirkpatrick. 2020. Covid-19 Changed How the World Does Science, Together. The New York Times, April 1. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/01/world/europe/coronavirus-science-research-cooperation.html [accessed May 25, 2020].
Arendt, Hannah. 1978 [1974]. Hannah Arendt: From an Interview with Roger Errera. New York Review of Books, October 26. https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1978/10/26/hannah-arendt-from-an-interview/ [accessed May 22, 2020].
Ball, Kirstie, Kevin Haggerty, and David Lyon, eds. 2014. Routledge Handbook of Surveillance Studies. London: Routledge.
Barr, Michael. 2011. Who’s Afraid of China? The Challenge of Chinese Soft Power. London: ZED Books.
Bourdieu, Pierre. 1991. Language and Symbolic Power. Edited by John B. Thompson. Translated by Gino Raymond and Matthew Adamson. Oxford, UK: Polity Press.
Bunn, Matthew. 2015. Reimagining Repression: New Censorship Theory and After. History and Theory 54: 25–44.
Burt, Richard. 1994. Administration of Aesthetics: Censorship, Political Criticism, and the Public Sphere. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Butler Judith. 1997. Excitable Speech: Politics of the Performative. London: Routledge.
Campbell, Anne, and Marie Uren. 2011. “The Invisibles”: Disability in China in the 21st Century. International Journal of Special Education 26 (1): 12–24.
Canales, Manuel, Sean and Mcnaughton. 2019. See Which Countries Fund the Most Scientific Research. National Geographic, May. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/magazine/2019/05/data-show-why-china-science-research-is-booming/ [accessed May 23, 2020].
China Daily. 2010. Harmonious Society. September 16. www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/19thcpcnationalcongress/2010-09/16/content_29714563.htm [accessed May 29, 2020].
Creemers, Rogier. 2017. Cyber China: Upgrading Propaganda, Public Opinion Work and Social Management for the Twenty-First Century. Journal of Contemporary China 26: 85–100.
Dandecker, Christopher. 1994. Surveillance, Power and Modernity. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
Dang, Shan, Geli Li, Junting Huang, Qiuming Li, Bo Peng, and Wanxia Yao. 2020. Physical and Psychological Status Survey of Clinical First-Line Support Medical Staff Fighting Against Corona Virus Disease 2019. Anhui Medical and Pharmaceutical Journal 24 (3): 500–504.
Darnton, Robert. 2014. Censors at Work: How States Shape Literature. New York: W.W. Norton and Company.
Das, Veena, 1997. Critical Events: An Anthropological Perspective on Contemporary India. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Ding, Lei, Wei Cai, Jianqing Ding, Xinxin Zhang, Yong Cai, Jianwei Shi, Qiming Liang, et al. 2020. An Interim Review of Lessons from the Novel Coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2) Outbreak in China. SCIENTIA SINICA Vitae 50 (3): 247–257.
Dreyfus, Hubert L. 2017. Background Practices: Essays on the Understanding of Being. Edited by Mark Wrathall. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Dukakis, Ali. 2020. China Rolls Out Software Surveillance for the COVID-19 Pandemic, Alarming Human Rights Advocates. ABC News Online, April 14. https://abcnews.go.com/International/china-rolls-software-surveillance-covid-19-pandemic-alarming/story?id=70131355 [accessed May 22, 2020].
Fang, Karen. 2018. Cinema Censorship and Media Citizenship in the Hong Kong Film Ten Years. Surveillance & Society 16 (2): 142–157.
Fang, Peng, Kang Shi, Xia Zhu, Peng Huang, Danmin Miao, Di Cui, Xufeng Liu, and Shengjun Wu. 2020. Analysis on Psychological Characteristics of the Public in the Epidemic of COVID-19. Infectious Disease Information (In Chinese) 33 (1): 30–35.
Foucault, Michel. 1990 [1976]. The History of Sexuality: An Introduction. Translated by Robert Hurley. New York: Vintage Press.
———. 1997. What Is Critique? In The Politics of Truth, edited by Sylvère Lotringer. Translated by Lysa Hochroth and Catehrine Porter, 41–81. Los Angeles, CA: Semiotext(e).
———. 2007. Security, Territory, Population. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
French, Martin, and Torin Monahan. 2020. Editorial: Dis-ease Surveillance: How Might Surveillance Studies Address COVID-19? Surveillance & Society 18 (1): 1–11.
Freshwater, Helen. 2004. Towards a Redefinition of Censorship. In Censorship & Cultural Regulation in the Modern Age, edited by Beate Müller, 225–242. Amsterdam, NL: Rodopi.
Galison, Peter. 2012. Blacked-Out Spaces: Freud, Censorship and the Re-Territorialization of Mind. The British Journal for History of Science 45 (2): 235–266.
Gan, Necter, Caitlin Hu, and Ivan Watson. 2020. Beijing Tightens Grip Over Coronavirus Research, Amid US-China Row on Virus Origin. CNN, April 16. https://edition.cnn.com/2020/04/12/asia/china-coronavirus-research-restrictions-intl-hnk/index.html [accessed May 23, 2020].
Georgetown Institute for Women, Peace, and Security, and Peace Research Institute Oslo. 2020. Tracking Sustainable Peace Through Inclusion, Justice, and Security for Women. Washington, DC: GIWPS and PRIO.
Gleiss, Marielle Stigum. 2015. Speaking Up for the Suffering (Br)other: Weibo Activism, Discursive Struggles, and Minimal Politics in China. Media, Culture & Society 37 (4): 513–529.
Goffman, Erving. 1971. Relations in Public: Microstudies of the Public Order. New York: Basic Books.
Haggerty, Kevin D., Ericson, Richard V., 2000. The Surveillant Assemblage. British Journal of Sociology 51 (4): 605–622.
Havel, Václav. [1978] 2018. The Power of the Powerless. London: Penguin.
Hier, Sean. 2007. The Surveillance Studies Reader. Buckingham, UK: Open University Press.
Hou, Rui. 2017. Neoliberal Governance or Digitalized Autocracy? The Rising Market for Online Opinion Surveillance in China. Surveillance & Society 15 (3/4): 418–424.
King, Gary, Jennifer Pan, and Margaret E. Roberts. 2013. How Censorship in China Allows Government Criticism but Silences Collective Expression. American Political Science Review 107 (2): 326–343.
Kirchgaessner, Stephanie, Emma Graham-Harrison, and Lily Kuo. 2020. China Clamping Down on Coronavirus Research, Deleted Pages Suggest. The Guardian, April 11. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/apr/11/china-clamping-down-on-coronavirus-research-deleted-pages-suggest [accessed August 12, 2020].
Kuo, Lily. 2020a. The New Normal: China's Excessive Coronavirus Public Monitoring Could Be Here to Stay. The Guardian, March 9. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/mar/09/the-new-normal-chinas-excessive-coronavirus-public-monitoring-could-be-here-to-stay [accessed May 23, 2020].
———. 2020b. China: Child Found Home Alone with Dead Grandfather Amid Coronavirus Lockdown. The Guardian, February 26. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/feb/26/china-child-found-home-alone-with-dead-grandfather-amid-coronavirus-lockdown [accessed May 23, 2020].
Lee, Siu-yau. 2016. Surviving Online Censorship in China: Three Satirical Tactics and their Impact. The China Quarterly 228: 1061–1080.
Levina, Marina. 2017. Under Lenin’s Watchful Eye: Growing Up in the Former Soviet Union. Surveillance & Society 15 (3/4): 529–534.
Lin, Bo. 2020. Power of Women Contribute to Fight COVID-19. China Sustainability Tribune 2020 (3): 61–62.
Lokot, Tetyana. 2018. Be Safe or Be Seen? How Russian Activists Negotiate Visibility and Security in Online Resistance Practices. Surveillance & Society 16 (3): 332–346.
Lyon, David. 2007. Surveillance Studies: An Overview. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
———. 2018. The Culture of Surveillance: Watching as a Way of Life. Cambridge, UK: Polity.
Marx, Gary 2018. Windows into the Soul: Surveillance and Society in an Age of High Technology. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.
Mitchell, Anna, and Larry Diamond. 2018. China's Surveillance State Should Scare Everyone. The Atlantic, February 2. https://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2018/02/china-surveillance/552203/?utm_source=share&utm_campaign=share [accessed May 21, 2020].
Monahan, Torin, and David Murakami Wood, eds. 2018. Surveillance Studies: A Reader. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Müller, Beate. 2004. Censorship and Cultural Regulation: Mapping the Territory. Censorship & Cultural Regulation in the Modern Age, edited by Beate Müller, 1–32. Amsterdam, NL: Rodopi.
Murakama Wood, David. 2013. What Is Global Surveillance? Towards a Relational Political Economy of the Global Surveillant Assemblage. Geoforum 49: 317–326.
Paltemaa, Lauri, Juha Antero Vuori, Mikael Mattlin, and Jouko Katajisto. 2020. Metainformation Censorship and the Creation of the Chinanet Bubble. Information, Communication & Society 23 (14): 2064–2080.
Post, Richard, ed. 1998. Censorship and Silencing: Practices of Cultural Regulation. Santa Monica, CA: Getty Research Institute Publications.
Psychological Society of Henan Province (PSHP). 2020. Social Mentality of the Public in Henan Province During the Epidemic of COVID-19. Psychological Research (In Chinese) 13 (1): 3–7.
Qian, Gang. 2020. What Has the Party Media Been Occupied with during the Pandemic. Radio Television Hong Kong. https://app3.rthk.hk/mediadigest/content.php?aid=2192 [accessed May 21, 2020].
Reeves, Joshua. 2017. Citizen Spies: The Long Rise of America's Surveillance Society. New York: New York University Press.
Repnikova, Maria. 2017. Media Politics in China: Improvising Power under Authoritarianism. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Ruan, Lotus, Jeffrey Knockel, and Masashi Crete-Nishihata. 2020. Censored Contagion: How Information on the Coronavirus is Managed on Chinese Social Media. https://citizenlab.ca/2020/03/censored-contagion-how-information-on-the-coronavirus-is-managed-on-chinese-social-media/ [accessed August 13, 2020].
Saich, Tony. 2010. Governance and Politics of China. 3rd edition. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave.
Schimpfössl, Elisabeth, and Ilya Yablokov. 2020. Post-Socialist Self-Censorship: Russia, Hungary and Latvia. European Journal of Communication 35 (1): 29–45.
Schimpfössl, Elisabeth, Ilya Yablokov, Olga Zeveleva, Taras Fedirko, and Peter Bajomi-Lazar. 2020. Self-Censorship Narrated: Journalism in Central and Eastern Europe. European Journal of Communication 35 (1): 3–11.
Schneider, Florian. 2018. China’s Digital Nationalism. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Shao, Li. 2018. The Dilemma of Criticism: Disentangling the Determinants of Media Censorship in China. Journal of East Asian Studies 18: 279–297.
She, Zongming. 2020. “The 10,000 Families Festive Dinner”: Wuhan’s Calmness Makes It Impossible for the Rest to Remain Calm. Beijing News, January 21. http://www.bjnews.com.cn/opinion/2020/01/21/677335.html [accessed May 25, 2020].
Sherry, Samantha. 2018. Introduction: New Perspectives on Censorship under Communism. The Slavonic and East European Review 96 (4): 601–613.
Standaert, Michael. 2020. Disabled Teenager in China Dies at Home Alone after Relatives Quarantined. The Guardian, January 30. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jan/30/disabled-teenager-in-china-dies-at-home-alone-after-relatives-quarantined [accessed May 23, 2020].
Staples, William G. 2000. Everyday Surveillance: Vigilance and Visibility in Postmodern Life. New York: Rowman and Littlefield.
State Internet Information Office. 2019. Provisions on the Governance of the Online Information Content Ecosystem. People’s Republic of China. https://www.chinalawtranslate.com/en/provisions-on-the-governance-of-the-online-information-content-ecosystem/ [accessed May 23, 2020].
Tong, Jingrong. 2009. Press Self-Censorship in China: A Case Study in the Transformation of Discourse. Discourse & Society 20 (5): 593–612.
United Nations. 2020. Policy Brief: COVID-19 and the Need for Action on Mental Health. New York: United Nations.
Verhoeven, Jef. 1985. Goffman’s Frame Analysis and Modern Micro-Sociological Paradigms. In Micro-Sociological Theory: Perspectives on Sociological Theory, edited by H.J. Helle and S.N. Eisenstadt, 71–100. London: SAGE Publications
Vuori, Juha Antero, and Lauri Paltemaa. 2015. The Lexicon of Fear: Chinese Internet Control Practice in Sina Weibo Microblog Censorship. Surveillance & Society 13 (3/4): 400–421.
Wang, Vivian, Amy Qin, and Sui-Lee Wee. 2020. Coronavirus Survivors Want Answers, and China Is Silencing Them. The New York Times, May 4. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/04/world/asia/china-coronavirus-answers.html?action=click&module=Spotlight&pgtype=Homepage [accessed May 22, 2020].
Wright, Joss. 2014. Regional Variation in Chinese Internet Filtering. Information, Communication & Society 17 (1): 121–141.
Xinhua News Press. 2020. Xi Jinping’s Important Instructions on the Epidemic of New Coronavirus Pneumonia. January 20. http://www.gov.cn/xinwen/2020-01/20/content_5471057.htm [accessed May 29, 2020].
Xu, Bin. 2017. The Politics of Compassion – The Sichuan Earthquake and Civic Engagement in China. Stanford, CT: Stanford University Press.
Xu, Zhangrun. 2020. Viral Alarm: When Fury Overcomes Fear. Journal of Democracy 31 (2): 5–23.
Yang, Fan. 2016. Rethinking China’s Internet Censorship: The Practice of Recoding and the Politics of Visibility. New Media & Society 18 (7): 1364–1381.
Yang, Guobin. 2009. The Power of the Internet in China: Citizen Activism Online. New York: Columbia University Press.
Yang, Mei. 2020. The White Brochure and the Green Brochure: Changes in COVID-19’s Diagnosis Standards. Bingdian Weekly, February 20. https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/vysNta8IU2wbRBv-c3aS4Q [accessed May 29, 2020].
Yang, Yingzhi, and Julie Zhu. 2020. Coronavirus Brings China’s Surveillance State Out of the Shadows. Reuters Online, February 7. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-health-surveillance-idUSKBN2011HO [accessed May 22, 2020].
Ye, Junrong, Zhichun Xia, Aixiang Xiao, Sijue Li, Jiankui Lin, Sha Nie, and Chen Wang. 2020. Investigation on Nurses' Anxiety Status and Influencing Factors During the Outbreak of COVID-19. Sichuan Psychology 33 (1): 11–14.
Ye, Zi. 2020. They Are the Most Beautiful Countermarching Peoples at the Frontline of the Epidemic. People’s Daily, February 6. http://paper.people.com.cn/rmrbhwb/html/2020-02/06/content_1969669.htm [accessed May 29, 2020].
Yu, Verna, and Emma Graham-Harrison. 2020. “This May Be the Last Piece I Write”: Prominent Xi Critic Has Internet Cut After House Arrest. The Guardian, February 16. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/feb/15/xi-critic-professor-this-may-be-last-piece-i-write-words-ring-true [accessed May 24, 2020].
Zeveleva, Olga. 2020. Towards a Bourdieusian Sociology of Self-Censorship: What We Can Learn From Journalists Adapting to Rapid Political Change in Crimea after 2014. European Journal of Communication 35 (1): 46–59.
Zhang, Joy Yueyue. 2012. The Cosmopolitanization of Science: Stem Cell Governance in China, Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
———. 2015. The “Credibility Paradox” in China’s Science Communication: Views From Scientific Practitioners. Public Understanding of Science 24 (8): 913–927.
Zhang, Joy Yueyue, and Michael Barr. 2013. Green Politics in China: Environmental Governance and State-Society Relations. London: Pluto Press.
Zhao, Kiki. 2020. The Coronavirus Story Is Too Big for China to Spin. The New York Times, February 14. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/14/opinion/china-coronavirus-social-media.html [accessed May 23, 2020].
Zidani, Sulafa. 2018. Represented Dreams: Subversive Expressions in Chinese Social Media as Alternative Symbolic Infrastructures. Social Media + Society 4 (4): 1–10.