Article Text
Abstract
Objectives The COVID-19 pandemic changed daily routines, including physical activity, which could influence physical and mental health. In our study, we describe physical activity and sedentary behaviour patterns in relation to the pandemic and estimate associations between anxiety and physical activity and sedentary behaviour in community-dwelling adults.
Design Cross-sectional study.
Setting Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Participants Between April and June 2020, a random sample of 1124 adults (≥18 years) completed an online questionnaire.
Primary and secondary outcomes The online questionnaire captured current walking, moderate intensity, vigorous intensity and total physical activity and sedentary behaviour (ie, sitting and leisure-based screen time), perceived relative changes in physical activity, sedentary and social behaviours since the pandemic, perceived seriousness and anxiety related to COVID-19, and sociodemographic characteristics. Differences in sociodemographic characteristics, perceived relative change in behaviour and current physical activity and sedentary behaviour were compared between adults with low and high anxiety.
Results Our sample (n=1047) included more females (60.3%) and fewer older adults (19.2%). Most participants (88.4%) considered COVID-19 as extremely or very serious and one-third (32.9%) felt extremely or very anxious. We found no differences (p>0.05) in current physical activity or sedentary behaviour by anxiety level. The largest perceived change in behaviours included social distancing, driving motor vehicles, use of screen-based devices, watching television and interactions with neighbours. We found anxiety-related differences (p<0.05) in perceived changes in various behaviours.
Conclusions Changes in physical activity, sedentary behaviour and social behaviour occurred soon after the COVID-19 pandemic was declared, and some of these changes differed among those with low and high anxiety.
- COVID-19
- epidemiology
- mental health
- public health
Data availability statement
No data are available. The ethics approval and written consent provided by participants in this study does not permit these data to be shared publicly. Data are available on reasonable request and in collaboration with the authors.
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Strengths and limitations of this study
Our study captured perceived changes in physical activity, sedentary and social behaviours as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic public health emergency response.
An online questionnaire was administered to a random sample of adults within the first 3 months of the WHO’s declaration of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Perceived changes in physical activity, sedentary and social behaviour since COVID-19 were examined in relation to a single-item measure of COVID-19 related anxiety.
Perceived changes in physical activity, sedentary and social behaviour measured within the first 3 months of the pandemic may not reflect current or future behaviours as the COVID-19 pandemic continues.
Despite retrospectively capturing change in behaviour since the COVID-19 pandemic, causality cannot be inferred based on the cross-sectional study design.
Background
In late 2019, the world became aware of a new and emerging virus, and on 11 March 2020, the WHO assessed COVID-19 as a pandemic.1 To reduce disease transmission, many countries, including Canada,2 implemented public health emergency orders that included the closures of educational and daycare facilities, non-essential businesses, and private and public recreation facilities (eg, playgrounds, outdoor exercise equipment and sports courts and fields). The Government of Canada developed several guidelines on social and physical distancing to slow the spread of COVID-19, including suggestions to work from home whenever possible.3 Despite the need for a rapid public health response to the COVID-19 crisis, the imposed restrictions on mobility, physical distancing and social interaction have impacted health.4
Anxiety is a risk factor for poor cardiovascular health5 and lower quality of life.6 The stress of rapidly adapting to new work, leisure, child-minding, school schedules and personal economic pressures have likely contributed to anxiety during the pandemic.7–10 The rapid transmission, high mortality rate and perceived risk of infection from COVID-19 in addition to social distancing, lockdowns and masking requirements have all contributed to anxiety levels.11–14 A study of seven middle-income Asian countries found being of younger age, not in a relationship, being in contact with people who contracted COVID-19 and worries about COVID-19 were risk factors of adverse mental health, while being male, having children, staying with six or more people, employment, higher perceived likelihood of surviving COVID-19, less exposure to health information, hand hygiene practices and mask wearing were protective factors against adverse mental health.15 A recent meta-analysis estimated that almost two-thirds of adults from Asian and European countries reported abnormal anxiety during the early stages of the pandemic.16 In Canada, Dozois17 found a fourfold increase in the prevalence from 4% to 16% in self-reported high or extreme anxiety among adults due to the pandemic.
Regular physical activity has been associated with a reduction in anxiety and is a recommended treatment for mild to moderate depression.18 Physical activity could improve mental health during the COVID-19 pandemic.19 Regular physical activity can reduce the risk of chronic health conditions including cardiovascular diseases, diabetes, hypertension, overweight or obesity, depression and anxiety, and certain types of cancers.20 Notably, decreases in physical activity and physical movement can result in immediate reductions in aerobic capacity,21 22 lean muscle tissue21 23 24 and increased fatigue.25 Moreover, physical activity can strengthen the immune system26 27 and reduce inflammation from conditions associated with cardiovascular disease, obesity and diabetes.28 Regardless of age, underlying health conditions can increase an adult’s susceptibility to COVID-19, often resulting in serious and prolonged hospitalisation.29–31
Aligned with COVID-19 specific physical activity recommendations elsewhere,32 the current Canadian public health guidelines advise individuals to be active by going outside while staying close to home and maintaining physical distancing from others outside of one’s household.3 Evidence on the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on physical activity is emerging.33–39 In the UK, Robinson et al 35 found that since the COVID-19 lockdown, 40% of adults reported exercising less, 34% reported being less physically active and 73% reported spending more time sitting. The researchers also found that previous psychiatric diagnosis was associated with perceived decreases in physical activity. Furthermore, those who perceived their mental health had declined since the COVID-19 lockdown undertook fewer metabolic equivalent (MET) minutes of physical activity per week.35 In the USA, the attenuation in physical activity during COVID-19 was greater for those achieving recommended levels of physical activity prior to the implementation of public health restrictions (eg, social isolation, social distancing and stay-at-home orders).34 Moreover, those who no longer met the physical activity recommendations during the COVID-19 pandemic had stronger depressive symptoms and stress.34 In Canada, Lesser and Nienhuis40 found that compared with previously active adults, a higher proportion of previously inactive adults decreased their physical activity during COVID-19.
Given these unprecedented times, it is important to investigate the extent to which the COVID-19 pandemic has affected health and physical activity among Canadian adults. The aims of this study were twofold: (1) to describe physical activity and sedentary behaviour patterns among adults in relation to the pandemic public health emergency response and (2) to estimate associations between anxiety related to COVID-19 and physical activity and sedentary behaviour patterns in community-dwelling adults.
Methods
Study and sample design
The study and sample design has been described elsewhere.37 Briefly, in April 2020, we sent a recruitment postcard with a link to an online questionnaire to a random sample of 25 000 north central Calgary households (Alberta, Canada). The timing of the survey coincided with the pandemic declaration1 and the Government of Alberta’s declared province-wide state of public health emergency (17 March–15 June 2020). The public health measures included no social gatherings, temporary business closures and capacity reductions, province-wide mask requirements and working from home. The public health measures prohibited attendance at public recreational facilities and private entertainment facilities (eg, gyms, swimming pools, arenas, community centres, playgrounds, skateboard parks but not golf courses and outdoor shooting ranges). The public health measures also prohibited indoor and outdoor private or public gatherings of more than 15 people (minimum of 2 m apart) but allowed members of the same household to gather at indoor and outdoor locations.
Eligible participants required internet access, resided in north central Calgary, were aged 18 years or older and had a current email address for receiving correspondence from the research team. All participants provided written informed consent prior to gaining access to the online questionnaire. After completing the questionnaire, participants received a pass to a local recreation facility and were entered into a prize draw to win one of two $500 VISA gift cards. One adult per household completed the online questionnaire (n=1124).
Measures
COVID-19 related anxiety
One item, adapted from a previous pandemic study on perceived risks,41 captured participants anxiety. Specifically, participants were asked ‘How anxious are you as a result of the current COVID-19/Coronavirus situation?’ (response options: extremely anxious, very anxious, somewhat anxious or not anxious at all). Due to the skewed distribution in responses, we collapsed responses into two categories (high anxiety (extremely or very anxious) and low anxiety (somewhat or not at all anxious)).
Seriousness of COVID-19
Also adapted from a previous study,41 one item asked participants to what extent they felt the current COVID-19/coronavirus situation was serious (ie, response options: extremely serious problem, a very serious problem, a somewhat serious problem, or not a serious problem). Similarly, due to the skewed distribution in responses, we collapsed responses into two categories (ie, extreme or very serious and somewhat or not serious).
Current physical activity
Three items from the International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ - Short Form) captured physical activity during the last 7 days.42 43 Participants reported the number of days per week they undertook vigorous physical activity (VPA), moderate physical activity (MPA) and walking for at least 10 min at a time. Participants then reported their usual time per day for these activities. We estimated weekly minutes of physical activity by multiplying the number of days by the minutes per day undertaking each physical activity. Established IPAQ procedures were implemented to minimise over-reporting of physical activity minutes.44 In addition, we estimated total weekly relative energy expenditure (METs) based on IPAQ procedures42 44 (total MET minutes per week = [VPA minutes × 8] + [MPA minutes × 4] + [walking minutes × 3.3]).
Current sedentary behaviour
Usual time sitting per day (eg, at work, home, doing coursework and during leisure) during the last 7 days was measured using an item from the IPAQ-Short Form.42 Participants also reported their average time per day during the last 7 days watching television or using other screen-based electronic devices (eg, for video or computer games, DVD/movies, internet and email) outside the workplace.45
Perceived relative behaviour change related to COVID-19
On a five-point scale (a lot less frequently, a little less frequently, about the same, a little more frequently or a lot more frequently), participants reported their perceived relative change in indoor and outdoor physical activity, walking in the neighbourhood alone or with family members, walking to stores, cafes or shops, sedentary behaviours (television viewing, gaming and use of screen-based devices), driving a motor vehicle, using public transit, visiting parks, using pathways, social interactions with neighbours and others, and social distancing, since the onset of the pandemic. Similar items have been used previously to capture change in physical activity behaviour due to COVID-19 in Canada36 37 and elsewhere.35
Sociodemographic characteristics
Captured sociodemographic characteristics included age (18–35, 36–60 or ≥60 years), sex (male or female), highest education completed (high school of less, trade/diploma/some university, bachelor degree or graduate degree), annual gross household income (≤$79 999, $80 000 to $119 999, ≥$120 000 or don’t know/refused to answer), marital status (married/common law or other), children <18 years of age in the household (yes or no), employment status (working full-time, working part-time, not employed, student/homemaker, retired or other), ethnicity (Caucasian, Chinese, Asian other, non-Asian other and multiple ethnicities) and dog ownership (owns dog or no dog).
Statistical analysis
A complete case analysis was undertaken given the small proportion of missing cases (6.8%). Pearson’s χ2 estimated the sociodemographic differences among those reporting COVID-19 as extremely/very serious and among those reporting high anxiety related to COVID-19. Independent t-tests estimated the differences in perceived relative change in physical activities, sedentary behaviours and social behaviours between those reporting low versus high anxiety related to COVID-19.
Sociodemographic-adjusted (marginal) means for weekly frequency (days/week) in walking, MPA, and VPA and total MET minutes per week, non-workplace screen-based minutes per day and total sitting minutes per day were estimated and compared between the low and high COVID-19 anxiety groups using generalised linear models (normal distribution and identity link function). Among those reporting participation on at least 1 day per week, covariate-adjusted means for weekly minutes of walking, MPA and VPA were also estimated and compared between the low and high COVID-19 anxiety groups using generalised linear models (gamma distribution and identity link function). The 95% CIs for the marginal means were estimated.
We compared differences in current total weekly physical activity and total daily sitting by perceived relative change in social distancing (no change or decrease vs increase; independent t-tests) and time outdoors (no change vs decrease vs increase; Welch’s Analysis of Variance with least significant difference pairwise comparisons) since COVID-19, as these changes reflect compliance with the enacted public health restrictions. Statistical significance for all tests was set at an alpha level of p<0.05. The analysis was undertaken using IBM Statistical Package for Social Sciences V.24.
Results
Sample characteristics
Our data collection (14 April–8 June 2020) coincided with the first 3 months of the declared state of public health emergency. The analytical sample included a complete data set of 1047 participants. The sample included mostly young to middle-aged adults, females, those completing bachelor or graduate degrees, households with incomes of ≥$80 000/year, full-time or part-time workers, Caucasians, household with no children, those married or in common law relationships and households without a dog (table 1).
The distribution in sociodemographic characteristics for the analytical sample and excluded cases were similar (p>0.05) for sex, age, household income, educational attainment, relationship status and dog ownership (results not shown). However, compared with the analytical sample, excluded cases included a higher proportion (p<0.05) of Caucasians (88.3%), households with a child at home (80%), homemakers or students (17.4%) and a lower proportion of retirees (4.3%), part-time workers (0%) and those unemployed (30.4%).
Seriousness of COVID-19 by sociodemographic characteristics
Most participants (88.4%) considered the COVID-19 situation as extremely or very serious (table 1). Compared with the analytical sample, a similar proportion (p=0.51) of excluded cases considered the COVID-19 as extremely or very serious (93.8%). Compared with their counterparts, a significantly (p<0.05) higher proportion of adults ≥60 years of age (93.5%), females (90.2%), retirees (93.6%) or other employment status (94.7%), and households with no children (91.3%) reported COVID-19 as extremely or very serious (table 1).
COVID-19 related anxiety by sociodemographic characteristics
Approximately one-third of participants (32.9%) reported feeling extremely or very anxious about COVID-19 (table 1). Compared with the analytical sample, excluded cases were more likely (p<0.05) to report feeling very or extremely anxious (51.9%). Compared with their counterparts, a significantly (p<0.05) higher proportion of those with high school or less education (41.5%), a household income <$80 000/year (39.9%), the unemployed (51.6%) or other employment status (50.9%), non-Chinese Asian (47.3%) and households with children (36.2%) reported feeling very or extremely anxious about COVID-19 (table 1).
Perceived relative change in physical activity, sedentary and social behaviours since COVID-19 pandemic by anxiety
On average, the largest perceived change in behaviours since the declaration of the pandemic included undertaking social distancing (increased), driving motor vehicles (decreased), using screen-based devices (increased), watching television (increased) and in-person interactions with neighbours (decreased) (table 2). Compared with those reporting less anxiety, those feeling very or extremely anxious about COVID-19, on average, perceived their physical activity with family (3.25 vs 3.07), time outdoors (3.16 vs 2.96) and use of pathways (3.20 vs 2.96) had increased in frequency (p<0.05) (table 2). In addition, perceived driving a motor vehicle decreased to a greater extent among those feeling very or extremely anxious about COVID-19 (1.65 vs 1.84, p<0.05). Perceived sedentary behaviour had increased since the pandemic; however, this change was larger (p<0.05) among those feeling very or extremely anxious (ie, watching television: 3.71 vs 3.95, playing video games: 3.21 vs 3.43 and using screen-based devices: 3.85 vs 4.03) (table 2).
Differences in current physical activity and sedentary behaviour by COVID-19 anxiety
Adjusting for sociodemographic characteristics, we found no significant differences (p<0.05) in current weekly physical activity (frequency, duration and relative energy expenditure) or daily sedentary behaviour (duration) between those reporting low versus high anxiety (table 3).
Difference in current physical activity and sedentary behaviour by perceived change in social distancing and time outdoors since COVID-19
Most participants (94.5%) perceived they had increased social distancing during the pandemic. We found no significant differences (p>0.05) in current mean total weekly physical activity nor mean daily total sitting by change in social distancing (perceived no change or decrease=2349.98 vs increase=2130.72 MET minutes/week, and perceived no change or decrease=281.11 vs increase=331.67 minutes/day, respectively) (table 4). Overall, 41.3% perceived their time outdoors had increased since COVID-19, while similar proportions perceived no change (29.8%) or a decrease (28.9%) in time outdoors. Compared with adults who perceived their time outdoors had decreased, those perceiving no change or an increase, on average, reported significantly (p<0.05) more total weekly physical activity (perceived decrease=1685.21 vs no change=2314.24 and increase=2338.05 MET min/week) and less daily sitting (perceived decrease=363.61 vs no change=326.87 and increase=306.45 min/day) (table 5).
Discussion
Congruent with findings elsewhere,35 we found that participants perceived their sedentary behaviour had increased due to COVID-19. Consistent with other findings,33–35 we also found that participants perceived changes in their physical activity due to COVID-19 and that these changes differed by anxiety related to COVID-19. Others have reported differences in perceived change in physical activity between those with and without pre-existing psychiatric conditions during the pandemic.35 We did not find any significant anxiety-related differences in current amounts of physical activity or sedentary behaviour.
The majority of Canadians (70%) are concerned about the impact of COVID-19 on the Canadian and world population’s health.46 We found most participants reported COVID-19 as extremely or very serious (88%). We also found a higher proportion of older adults, females, retirees and households with no children reported COVID-19 as extremely or very serious relative to other groups. These differences might reflect that some groups (eg, older adults) are at higher risk of serious health complications due to COVID-19.47 48 Despite males having a higher risk of developing more serious health complications from COVID-19,47 48 speculatively, females may consider the COVID-19 situation more serious due the rapid changes in daily routines (eg, closures of schools an daycare facilities, balancing at home work and child-minding). While we did not examine differences in perceived seriousness of COVID-19 based on pre-existing health conditions, Ramage-Morin and Polsky46 found higher concern associated with COVID-19 among those with existing health conditions.
Anxiety levels reported in Canada17 and elsewhere16 have worsened in only a short period of time since the COVID-19 pandemic began. We found almost one-third of participants reported very high or extreme anxiety related to COVID-19 within the first 3 months of the pandemic. This is of concern given that high anxiety negatively impacts health,5 6 and the pandemic is still ongoing. Compared with other groups, higher proportions of those with low education, low household incomes, unemployed, non-Chinese Asians and with children reported very high or extreme anxiety related to COVID-19. Other studies have reported associations between sociodemographic characteristics and anxiety during the early stages of the pandemic.49 50 Congruent with our findings, cohabitating, having children and having lower of income have been associated with higher anxiety during COVID-19 in European studues49 50; however, in Asian countries having no children at home, being single or separated, having higher education and being younger adult (<30 years) have been associated with adverse mental health during COVID-19.15 We did not find higher anxiety among older adults that might reflect our potentially healthier sample. Notably, the effects of age on anxiety during COVID-19 reported elsewhere appears to be mixed.15 50 Higher anxiety levels reported in our study and elsewhere might reflect the stress of individuals and families rapidly adapting to new daily schedules, economic pressures, or concerns about contracting or transmitting COVID-19.7–12 Canadian governments and health authorities have provided online resources to combat mental health conditions due to the pandemic51 52; however, individual, environmental and policy approaches that target the determinants of these conditions are needed.53 54
Encouraging people to be more physically active, even under a state of public health emergency, is important for supporting health.32 55 Canadians are being advised to be active by going outside while staying close to home and maintaining physical distancing.3 Approximately 95% of our sample reported increasing their social distancing behaviour since COVID-19 suggesting high compliance with physical distancing restrictions. Perceived change in social distancing as well as interactions with others was similar regardless of anxiety levels. Nevertheless, almost 29% of participants perceived their time outdoors had decreased since the pandemic despite the Canadian government recommending people be active outdoors. Notably, those with high anxiety decreased time outdoors while those with low anxiety increased time outdoors. These trends were also found for pathway use. While we did not find differences in current physical activity and sedentary behaviour by level of anxiety, those who perceived their outdoor time had decreased accumulated less physical activity and more sitting compared with those who increased or did not change their outdoor time. Adults with higher anxiety should be encouraged to spend more time outdoors during the pandemic as it could provide mental health benefits via opportunities for physical activity18 and connections with nature.40 56
Increases in sedentary behaviour corresponding with COVID-19 restrictions have been found.35 We found, on average, participants reported sitting approximately 6 hours per day and spending just over 3 hours per day on recreational screen-based activity aligned with the maximum of 8 hours of sedentary and 3 hours of screen time per day promoted by the adult Canadian 24 hour Movement Guidelines.57 Alarmingly, participants reported perceived increases in sedentary behaviour (eg, watching television, play video games and use of screen-based devices) during the pandemic. Despite no differences in current sitting or leisure-based screen time, the perceived changes in sedentary behaviour were more pronounced among those with higher anxiety. The public health emergency restrictions that encouraged people to perform their usually daily tasks at home (eg, working and schooling) might have inadvertently provided more opportunity for home-based sedentary behaviour. Physical activity recommendations specific to COVID-19 exist, yet these recommendations do not explicitly address sedentary behaviour.3 32 Recommending and providing more opportunities for outdoor activity and implementing multilevel interventions that target sedentary behaviour in the home setting58 59 could reduce sitting during the pandemic.
We did not have comparison pre-COVID-19 physical activity data; however, the majority of our sample (78.8%) was moderately active (ie, ≥600 MET minutes per week)44 despite the pandemic. This level of physical activity might be considered high given that other studies have reported decreases in physical activity due to COVID-19.33–35 38 We cannot conclude if any changes in total accumulated physical activity have occurred due to the pandemic; however, our findings might suggest some changes in behaviour have supported the maintenance or increases in physical activity (eg, being physically active at home and walking in the neighbourhood either along or with family). It is possible that some adults in our sample increased while others decreased their physical activity40 or that others substituted their physical activities with those that could be safely undertaken under the pandemic restrictions.39 While the goal of encouraging adults to accumulate health-enhancing physical activity has not changed,60 strategies now need to adapt to the current restrictions (and opportunities) that have emerged during the pandemic.61 62
Our study has several limitations. Despite including a measure of perceived behaviour change, causality cannot be inferred from our study. Our study represents the relationships between physical activity, sedentary behaviour and anxiety captured within the first 3 months of the pandemic. Given the ongoing public health restrictions, the emergence of second and third waves of increased infection rates, and the launch of the COVID-19 vaccine programme across Canada, our findings may not generalise to the current situation. Given the lack of available prepandemic data for our sample, we are unable to rule-out the potential effects of pre-existing anxiety, psychopathologies or health conditions on levels of COVID-19 related anxiety during the early stages of the pandemic.
The self-report measures of physical activity and anxiety included in our study may be subject to social desirability and reporting bias. Our survey included a single-item (global) measure of COVID-19 related anxiety; however, this may not have fully captured the anxiety experienced during the pandemic and in particular anxiety experienced in relation to specific life events (eg, job loss, illness or death of a family member or friend and isolation from family and friends). The higher levels of education and income of participants, the low response rate and sampling of households from north central Calgary communities may also limit the generalisability of our findings.
Conclusions
The COVID-19 pandemic had immediate impacts on physical activity and sedentary behaviour. Encouraging adults, and in particular those with high anxiety, to be physically active outdoors while maintaining physical distancing could support the accumulation of physical activity during the pandemic. The pandemic has further highlighted the importance of encouraging physical activity and discouraging sedentary behaviour in general as a means of promoting health and well-being in the community. To inform future public health strategies, more research is needed to better understand how people have adapted their daily routines to maintain their physical activity levels during the pandemic. In addition to promoting physical activity and discouraging sedentary behaviour, interventions that directly address the increased anxiety associated with infectious disease pandemics are also needed.
Data availability statement
No data are available. The ethics approval and written consent provided by participants in this study does not permit these data to be shared publicly. Data are available on reasonable request and in collaboration with the authors.
Ethics statements
Ethics approval
The University of Calgary Conjoint Health Research Ethics Board granted ethics approval for the study (REB19-1910).
References
Footnotes
Contributors GRM: conceptualisation, methodology, supervision, writing – original draft preparation, writing – review and editing, supervision and funding acquisition. JAP: conceptualisation, methodology, project administration and writing – review and editing. DG: data curation and writing – review and editing. PKD-B: conceptualisation, methodology, supervision, writing – review and editing, supervision and funding acquisition.
Funding Funding support for this study was provided by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research (FDN-154331) and Vivo for Healthier Generations Society. Vivo is a charitable enterprise in Calgary, Alberta, on a mission to raise healthier generations in that city and beyond. In addition to operating a local recreation centre, Vivo undertakes research and innovation that is focussed on developing, testing and scaling novel healthy living interventions with the community.
Competing interests None declared.
Patient and public involvement Patients and/or the public were not involved in the design, or conduct, or reporting, or dissemination plans of this research.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.