Exposure-lag response of air temperature on COVID-19 incidence in twelve Italian cities: A meta-analysis,☆☆

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2022.113099Get rights and content
Under a Creative Commons license
open access

Highlights

  • City-specific statistical models quantify delayed effects of air temperature on daily COVID-19 incidence.

  • Exposure and lag effects pooled from first-stage analysis using random effects meta-analysis.

  • Non-linear cumulative exposure response curve; peak risk at 15.1 °C and declining risk at lower and higher temperatures.

  • The lowest cumulative risk at 0.2 °C is 0.72 [0.56,0.91] times that at 15.1 °C.

Abstract

The exposure-lag response of air temperature on daily COVID-19 incidence is unclear and there have been concerns regarding the robustness of previous studies. Here we present an analysis of high spatial and temporal resolution using the distributed lag non-linear modelling (DLNM) framework. Utilising nearly two years’ worth of data, we fit statistical models to twelve Italian cities to quantify the delayed effect of air temperature on daily COVID-19 incidence, accounting for several categories of potential confounders (meteorological, air quality and non-pharmaceutical interventions). Coefficients and covariance matrices for the temperature term were then synthesised using random effects meta-analysis to yield pooled estimates of the exposure-lag response with effects presented as the relative risk (RR) and cumulative RR (RRcum). The cumulative exposure response curve was non-linear, with peak risk at 15.1 °C and declining risk at progressively lower and higher temperatures. The lowest RRcum at 0.2 °C is 0.72 [0.56,0.91] times that of the highest risk. Due to this non-linearity, the shape of the lag response curve necessarily varied by temperature. This work suggests that on a given day, air temperature approximately 15 °C maximises the incidence of COVID-19, with the effects distributed in the subsequent ten days or more.

Keywords

Air temperature
COVID-19 incidence
Delayed effects
Italy
Time-series
Meta-analysis
Distributed lag non-linear model

Cited by (0)

This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

☆☆

This study used publicly available datasets and did not involve human subjects or experimental animals.