Open Access

Detection of SARS‑CoV‑2 Delta, Omicron and XBB variant using colorimetric reverse‑transcription loop‑mediated isothermal amplification and specific primers

  • Authors:
    • Kheng Oon Low
    • Nurhezreen Md Iqbal
    • Azrin Ahmad
    • Nor Azfa Johari
  • View Affiliations

  • Published online on: March 27, 2025     https://doi.org/10.3892/wasj.2025.338
  • Article Number: 50
  • Copyright : © Low et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of Creative Commons Attribution License [CC BY 4.0].

Metrics: Total Views: 0 (Spandidos Publications: | PMC Statistics: )
Total PDF Downloads: 0 (Spandidos Publications: | PMC Statistics: )


Abstract

Even with global vaccination efforts, COVID‑19 continues due to the emergent of new and more transmissible variants of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS‑CoV‑2) that evade immunity. Monitoring these variants is costly, often requiring whole‑genome sequencing. Therefore, there is a need for more cost‑effective and rapid alternatives for the identification of variant‑specific samples. Reverse‑transcription loop‑mediated isothermal amplification (RT‑LAMP) provides a more affordable and rapid method for detecting SARS‑CoV‑2 compared to other molecular tests. The present study designed colorimetric RT‑LAMP assays that target mutations associated with specific SARS‑CoV‑2 lineages. These assays were tested on 347 confirmed SARS‑CoV‑2 RNA samples. The results revealed promising accuracy: 92.18% for Omicron‑specific primers, followed by 80.64% for XBB and 71.57% for Delta. This assay effectively distinguishes the variants of concern, Delta, Omicron and XBB, without the use of costly equipment/facilities and does not require the specialized training of personnel. This development supports the use of RT‑LAMP as a valuable tool in healthcare systems battling COVID‑19.

Introduction

Since its emergence in 2019, COVID-19, driven by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2), continues to spread at a rapid pace. By March, 2024, the number of deaths reached 7 million worldwide, of which Malaysia recorded 37,349 (https://data.moh.gov.my/dashboard/covid-19). Of note, >1,560 SARS-CoV-2 lineages have been identified [PANGO Lineages network (https://cov-lineages.org/lineage_list.html; updated on December 4, 2024)]. Novel variants of concern (VOCs) with high mutation rates are a challenge. These variants, such as Delta and Omicron, become more infectious and evade vaccines to some degree, hindering pandemic control (1,2).

Of note, five major VOCs have emerged sequentially: Alpha (B.1.1.7/Q.*), Beta (B.1.351/), Gamma (P.1/P.1.*), Delta (B.1.617.2/AY.*) and Omicron (BA.1.1.529/BA.*). Delta, first detected in April, 2021, became dominant, but was then replaced by Omicron in December, 2021. The XBB variant was reported in Malaysia in September, 2022.

The monitoring of new variants through DNA sequencing is crucial for informing public health decisions. Canada leads in sequencing, analyzing almost 13% of positive cases. Despite having the 28th highest number of confirmed cases globally, Malaysia has sequenced <1% of these. (EpiCoV database in GISAID; https://www.gisaid.org/submission-tracker-global/). In developing nations, such as Myanmar, Libya and Azerbaijan, this issue is particularly acute, with sequencing coverage being <0.05%

While DNA sequencing is the gold standard, some researchers propose using reverse transcription-quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR) with specific probes for more rapid and cost-effective variant surveillance (3). However, RT-qPCR may still be costly for some countries. Researchers are exploring affordable point-of-care tests for the diagnosis of COVID-19. RT-loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) shows promise as a reliable and rapid diagnostic tool (4,5). This method can detect the targeted region in a genome with considerable specificity and sensitivity in <40 min, without the necessity of a real-time thermocycler. The LAMP method utilizes a DNA polymerase and four primers to hybridize six regions on target DNA (6). An inner primer initiates LAMP by recognizing the sense and antisense strands of the target. Strand displacement DNA synthesis, driven by an outer primer, produces a single-stranded DNA template for further synthesis with the second inner and outer primers, forming a stem-loop structure. In the subsequent LAMP cycles, one inner primer binds to the loop of the product, initiating more synthesis and generating both the original and a new stem-loop DNA with an extended stem. Signal can be captured based on the presence of amplification through gel electrophoresis, colour change or fluorescence detection. An improved LAMP method utilizes two extra primers (termed forward loop and backward loop) which targets loop region (7). This six-primer LAMP reaction significantly reduces the signal generation to 15-30 min.

The present study developed RT-LAMP primers aimed at detecting specific mutations found in the Delta, Omicron and XBB variants. This novel assay successfully distinguished between samples containing these variants, providing an indirect method to monitor their prevalence. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report on the use of RT-LAMP for VOC detection without additional probes or primers. The present study proves that RT-LAMP can be a more cost-effective alternative to DNA sequencing and RT-qPCR for variant surveillance.

Materials and methods

Isolation of RNA

All SARS-CoV-2 clinical samples examined in the present study were verified using whole-genome sequencing (WGS) (Fig. 1). RNA isolation from swabs was performed according to the manufacturer's guidelines (Nucleospin RNA Virus, Macherey-Nagel). The presence of SARS-CoV-2 virus was confirmed using RT-qPCR according to manufacturer's protocol (Viasure SARS-CoV-2 del 69/70, ORF1ab & N genes Detection kit, Cretest Biotec). Positive samples with Ct (threshold cycle) value ≤30 were selected and were used for WGS. Ct value is the cycle number where the amplification curve intersects with the threshold line and was determined automatically using real-time PCR software (CFX96 Touch Real-time PCR Thermal System, Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc.). Sequencing libraries were created using the Illumina COVIDSeq assay kit and sequenced on Illumina MiSeq. Subsequently, the raw sequencing data underwent processing with bioinformatics tools to produce and identify assembled viral consensus sequences. Nextclade Web (https://clades.nextstrain.org/) is an online bioinformatics tool that performs alignment, mutation calling, clade assignment, phylogenetic placement and quality control checks. It was then used to evaluate the consensus sequences for quality assessment and to designate its nomenclature. The tool analyzes various sequence metrics, including non-N ambiguous bases, the number of nucleotide gaps (N's), and the positions of N runs in the genome. The consensus sequence (FASTA) files along with its associated metadata were uploaded to the public sequence database, Global Initiative on Sharing All Influenza Data (GISAID; https://www.gisaid.org).

Alignment of SARS-CoV-2 genome sequences and RT-LAMP primer design

Genome sequences of SARS-CoV-2 were downloaded from GISAID. The sequences includes representation from various continents and variants such as Alpha (B.1.1.7, Q.1-Q.8), Beta (B.1.351, B.1.351.2, B.1.351.3), Gamma (P.1, P.1.1, P.1.2), Delta (B.1.617.2), Omicron (B.1.1.529) and XBB (XBB.1.16.*). This comprehensive selection was used to pinpoint unique regions for RT-LAMP primer design, aiming for an assay that is as sensitive, specific, and accurate as possible for each targeted variant. The sequence quality assessment was made by implements a variety of quality control metrics such as missing data, mixed sites, private mutations, mutation clusters, frame shifts and stop codons with Nextclade (https://clades.nextstrain.org/). To perform a comparative analysis, the full genome sequences were aligned at the base level utilizing the MAFFT-L-INS-I multiple sequence alignment program (https://mafft.cbrc.jp/alignment/software/). The Wuhan-Hu-1 sequence was set as the reference sequence to be aligned with. The selection of primer binding sites was based on the unique regions specific for each SARS-CoV-2 variant. The PrimerExplorer V5 program (available at https://primerexplorer.jp/e/) was then used to design each RT-LAMP primer sets (each containing four to six primers). The sequences of all primer sets are listed in Table I. The hybridization region for each LAMP primers on target variants is illustrated in Fig. 2.

Table I

Primer sequences used in the present study.

Table I

Primer sequences used in the present study.

VariantPrimer setTarget mutationSequence (5'-3')
DeltaLRTKS:L452R and S:T478KF3: CAAACTGGAAAGATTGCTGAT
   B3: ACCATATGATTGTAAAGGAAAGT
   FIP: CGGTAATTATAATTACCACCAACCTTGATTTTACAGGCTGCGT
   BIP: GTTTAGGAAGTCTAATCTCAAACCTAGGCCCCATTACAAGGTT
   LB: TTCAACTGAAATCTATC
OmicronSet5+S:E452AF3: CTGTATAGATTGTTTAGGAAGTCT
   B3: TGGTGCATGTAGAAGTTCAA
   FIP: GCAACACCATTACAAGGTTTGTTACTTTTGAGAGAGATATTTC AACTGA
   BIP: TTACGATCATATAGTTTCCGACCCAAGAAAGTACTACTACTCT GTATGG
   LF: CCGGCCTGATAGATT
   LB: CTTATGGTGTTGGTCA
XBBXBBA19326GF3: GACAAATTCACAGATGGTGTA
   B3: CTGTCAGAGTAATAGAAAAATGGTA
   FIP: AGGTTAGATAGCACTCTAGTGTCAAGCCTATTTTGGAATTGCA ATGT
   BIP: TAACTTGCCTGGTTGTGATGGTAAAAGCATTTTATCAAAAGCC
   LF: GGAATTAGCAGGATATCTATC
   LB: GCAGTTTGTATGTAAATAAAC

[i] All the primers were designed using the PrimerExplorer V5 program. The bold letter represents the target mutation on respective variant. For primer set LRTK, only five primers were suggested by PrimerExplorer V5. All primer sets were tested in separate reactions on different SARS-CoV-2 variants. The single underline indicates the 5' region of inner primer FIP and BIP; the double underline: 3' indicates the region of inner primers FIP and BIP. F3, forward outer; FIP, forward inner; LF, loop forward; B3, backward outer; BIP, backward inner; LB, loop backward.

The oligonucleotides were purchased through IDT. All the designed primer sets were tested on synthetic SARS-CoV-2 RNA (Twist Bioscience synthetic RNA control), non-template control (NTC) or verified patient RNA sample. The primer sets with optimal performance were selected for further testing and analysis. In a reaction volume (25 µl), the primer concentration (10X) were settled as follows: 2 µM for F3 and B3, 4 µM for LF and LB, and 16 µM for FIP and BIP.

Control RNA

Synthetic SARS-CoV-2 RNA for SARS-CoV-2 variants was purchased from Twist Bioscience [Control 14 B.1.1.7_710528 (Alpha B.1.1.7), Control 16 EPI_ISL_678597 (Beta B.1.351), Control 17 EPI_ISL_792683 (Gamma P.1), Control 23 EPI_ISL_1544014 (Delta B.617.2)]. RNA samples were diluted in nuclease-free water to 1,000 copies/µl, aliquoted and kept in -80˚C as working stock.

Colorimetric RT-LAMP assay

A WarmStart Colorimetric RT-LAMP 2X Master Mix (New England Biolabs) was used to perform RT-LAMP-based detection of SARS-CoV-2. The reaction mixture is composed of Master Mix (12.5 µl), 10X primer mix (2.5 µl), RNA sample (2.5 µl) and dH2O up to 25 µl. The mixture was incubated in a heating block at 60˚C for 60 min or until a color changes appeared. The amplified product was evaluated visually by color, where a yellow hue indicates the presence of the target variant and a pink hue shows its absence.

Collection of clinical samples

Multiple validations were conducted on real clinical specimens, which were leftover RNA-extracted samples from an in-house project on SARS-CoV-2 genomic surveillance. A total of 347 RNA samples, validated as either positive or negative for Delta, Omicron, and XBB SARS-CoV-2, were tested simultaneously with the colorimetric RT-LAMP assay developed in this study. The specificity was determined by testing with another SARS-CoV-2 variant.

The National Institutes of Biotechnology Malaysia confirmed that no ethics approval or patient consent were required for the present study due to the following reasons: The study was conducted as part of a government-funded initiative during the COVID-19 pandemic, which prioritized rapid response to public health needs. The samples used for the project were provided by government hospitals specifically for surveillance and sequencing purposes, in alignment with national public health objectives. Under such circumstances, the project fell within the scope of public health surveillance, which is often exempt from individual consent requirements. Additionally, the study adhered to strict data protection protocols, ensuring that all samples were anonymized and used solely for the purpose of developing diagnostic methods to combat the pandemic.

Statistical analysis

Diagnostic studies were analyzed based on the extracted true positive (TP), false positive (FP), false negative (FN) and true negative (TN) data. The diagnostic performance of RT-LAMP was evaluated by examining the accuracy, sensitivity and specificity. The equations for calculations were as follows: Accuracy=(TP + TN)/n; sensitivity=TP/(TP + FN); specificity=TN/(TN + FP), where n=the total no. of samples.

Results

RT-LAMP primer performance

Cross-reactivity against all available synthetic RNA VOCs was performed to assess the performance of the specific LAMP primers in targeting the respective variants. As illustrated in Fig. 3A, delta- and omicron-specific primers exhibited a positive reaction only in the presence of targeted VOC. At the time of the experiment, no VOC XBB synthetic RNA was available. Nonetheless, XBB-specific primers did not exhibit a positive reaction against all other tested synthetic RNA samples. Subsequent test using verified XBB sample showed positive reaction (data not shown).

To assess the optimal reaction time, RT-LAMP was performed at different time points from 10 to 60 min. The optimal reaction time was 30 min for all tested VOC-specific primers (Fig. 3B). A reaction time >60 min was not tested due to the limitation of LAMP reactions where non-specific reactions would be observed, as reported by previous research (8).

RT-LAMP assays on clinical samples

The performance of the Delta-, Omicron- and XBB-specific primer sets were tested on clinical specimens and the results are presented in Table II. A total of 347 clinical specimens were tested (203 positive and 144 negative samples). These samples were validated as positive for SARS-CoV-2 through RT-qPCR and sequencing. The reactions were performed in duplicate due to the limited amount of sample volume. As shown in Table II, the Ct values (quantified using RT-qPCR), the variant identity (based on sequencing result and categorization according to the Pangolin lineage assigner (https://cov-lineages.org/resources/pangolin.html), the result for the two RT-LAMP replicates, and the test outcome. True positive (or true negative) were classified as having both replicates to be correct, and false positive (or false negative) as either one replicate to be incorrect.

Table II

Comparison between sequencing and RT-LAMP results for clinical samples.

Table II

Comparison between sequencing and RT-LAMP results for clinical samples.

 Sequencing resultsdRT-LAMP resultse 
SampleaGISAID IDbCtcVariantPango lineageReplicate 1Replicate 2Outcomef
Delta       
GS0677EPI_ISL_1189993116.11DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0679EPI_ISL_1189993315.74DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0681EPI_ISL_1189993420.39DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0682EPI_ISL_1189993524.49DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0683EPI_ISL_1189993625.45DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0685 EPI_ISL_1189993820.08DeltaAY.75++TP
GS0686 EPI_ISL_1189993920.25DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0688 EPI_ISL_1189994022.91DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0689 EPI_ISL_1189994124.39DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0690 EPI_ISL_1189994227.62DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0691 EPI_ISL_1189994324.93DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0694 EPI_ISL_1189994521.38DeltaAY.23++TP
GS0695 EPI_ISL_1189994623.02DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0696 EPI_ISL_1189994721.25DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0697 EPI_ISL_1189994817.66DeltaAY.23++TP
GS0698 EPI_ISL_1189994920.02DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0730 EPI_ISL_1189995720.96DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0762 EPI_ISL_1189996722.43DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0765 EPI_ISL_1189997024.8DeltaAY.76++TP
GS0773 EPI_ISL_1189997324.67DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0774 EPI_ISL_1189997416.69DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0775 EPI_ISL_1189997516.29DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0786 EPI_ISL_1189998215.50DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0791 EPI_ISL_1189998517.04DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0792 EPI_ISL_1189998619.02DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0794 EPI_ISL_1189998822.51DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0796 EPI_ISL_1189999021.33DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0797 EPI_ISL_1189999119.38DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0798 EPI_ISL_1189999217.18DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0799 EPI_ISL_1189999316.61DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0800 EPI_ISL_1189999419.11DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0801 EPI_ISL_1189999514.89DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0802 EPI_ISL_1189999620.88DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0804 EPI_ISL_1189999819.35DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0806 EPI_ISL_1189999928.7DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0809 EPI_ISL_1190000026.89DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0821 EPI_ISL_1190000931.07DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0829 EPI_ISL_1320306721.18DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0846 EPI_ISL_1190001322.77DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0900 EPI_ISL_1190003324.55DeltaAY.68++TP
GS0903 EPI_ISL_1190003420.99DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0904 EPI_ISL_1190003526.29DeltaAY.68++TP
GS0905 EPI_ISL_1190003626.98DeltaAY.79++TP
GS0906 EPI_ISL_1190003715.06DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0907 EPI_ISL_1190003827.11DeltaAY.68++TP
GS0908 EPI_ISL_1190003925.4DeltaAY.59++TP
GS0910 EPI_ISL_1190004018.69DeltaAY.59++TP
GS1122 EPI_ISL_1320299525.50OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS1121 EPI_ISL_1320299417.92OmicronBA.1.1+-FP
GS1119 EPI_ISL_1320299325.17OmicronBA.1.1-+FP
GS1118 EPI_ISL_1320299225.88OmicronBA.1.1+-FP
GS1128 EPI_ISL_1320299918.16OmicronBA.1.15--TN
GS1117 EPI_ISL_1320299126.53OmicronBA.1--TN
GS1116 EPI_ISL_1320299019.46OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1113 EPI_ISL_1320298718.70OmicronBA.1.1+-FP
GS1112 EPI_ISL_1320298620.50OmicronBA.2.10--TN
GS1111 EPI_ISL_1320298525.14OmicronBA.1.14++FP
GS1110 EPI_ISL_1320308825.47OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS1109 EPI_ISL_1320308725.95OmicronBA.1.1-+FP
GS1108 EPI_ISL_1320308620.20OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1107 EPI_ISL_1320308524.21OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS1106 EPI_ISL_1320308420.40OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1105 EPI_ISL_1320308315.91OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS1104 EPI_ISL_1320308216.13OmicronBA.1.1+-FP
GS1103 EPI_ISL_1320308119.20OmicronBA.1.1-+FP
GS1102 EPI_ISL_1320308025.02OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1101 EPI_ISL_1320307918.37OmicronBA.2--TN
GS1100 EPI_ISL_1320307824.09OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS1099 EPI_ISL_1320307724.16OmicronBA.1.1+-FP
GS1098 EPI_ISL_1320307623.65OmicronBA.2++FP
GS0924 EPI_ISL_1190005029.69OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS0921 EPI_ISL_1190004830.12OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS0920 EPI_ISL_1190004721.72OmicronBA.1.1+-FP
GS0919 EPI_ISL_1190004620.45OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS0918 EPI_ISL_1190004517.68OmicronBA.2--TN
GS0917 EPI_ISL_1190004422.27OmicronBA.2++FP
GS0898 EPI_ISL_1190003222.72OmicronBA.1--TN
GS0892 EPI_ISL_1190003118.46OmicronBA.1.1+-FP
GS0891 EPI_ISL_1190003026.48OmicronBA.1.1+-FP
GS0887 EPI_ISL_1190002927.01OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS0884 EPI_ISL_1190002821.13OmicronBA.1.1+-FP
GS0883 EPI_ISL_1190002723.1OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS0882 EPI_ISL_1190002625.84OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS0881 EPI_ISL_1190002525.71OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS0877 EPI_ISL_1190002420.66OmicronBA.2-+FP
GS0871 EPI_ISL_1190002329.00OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS0868 EPI_ISL_1190002219.29OmicronBA.1++FP
GS0865 EPI_ISL_1190002117.38OmicronBA.2--TN
GS0864 EPI_ISL_1190002015.86OmicronBA.2--TN
GS0863 EPI_ISL_1190001919.58OmicronBA.2--TN
GS0862 EPI_ISL_1190001821.14OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS0861 EPI_ISL_1190001718.89OmicronBA.2--TN
GS0853 EPI_ISL_1190001617.88OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS0851 EPI_ISL_1190001518.28OmicronBA.2--TN
GS0849 Omicron EPI_ISL_1190001424.76OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS0940 EPI_ISL_1197617117.02OmicronBA.2++TP
GS0931 EPI_ISL_1190005629.58OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0930 EPI_ISL_1190005525.31OmicronBA.2++TP
GS0929 EPI_ISL_1190005425.27DeltaAY.79--TN
GS0928 EPI_ISL_1190005323.26OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0927 EPI_ISL_1190005214.59OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0925 EPI_ISL_1190005116.62OmicronBA.1++TP
GU0139 EPI_ISL_1365138025.03OmicronBA.1.1+-FN
GU0138 EPI_ISL_1365137922.43OmicronBA.2.3++TP
GU0137 EPI_ISL_1365137817.24OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0136 EPI_ISL_1365137717.13OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GU0135 EPI_ISL_1365137626.75OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0134 EPI_ISL_1365137526.51OmicronBA.2.10++TP
GU0133 EPI_ISL_1365137419.09OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GU0132 EPI_ISL_1365137324.9OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GU0131 EPI_ISL_1365137220.32OmicronBA.2.3++TP
GU0130 EPI_ISL_1365137123.61OmicronBA.2.3++TP
GU0129 EPI_ISL_1365137024.37OmicronBA.2.3++TP
GU0128 EPI_ISL_1365136925.13OmicronBA.2.3++TP
GU0127 EPI_ISL_1365136817.14OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0126 EPI_ISL_1365136718.96OmicronBA.2.10++TP
GU0125 EPI_ISL_1365136620.55OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0124 EPI_ISL_1365136518.36OmicronBA.2.3++TP
GU0123 EPI_ISL_1365136426.36OmicronBA.2.10++TP
GU0122 EPI_ISL_1365136328.94OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0121 EPI_ISL_1365136227.19OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GU0120 EPI_ISL_1365136118.29OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GU0119 EPI_ISL_1365136021.87OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0118 EPI_ISL_1365135925.15OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0117 EPI_ISL_1365135821.7OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GU0116 EPI_ISL_1365135720.44OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0115 EPI_ISL_1365135623.13OmicronBA.2.3-+FN
GU0114 EPI_ISL_1365135518.22OmicronBA.2.10++TP
GU0216 EPI_ISL_1365140014.69OmicronBA.5++TP
GU0215 EPI_ISL_1365139918.62OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0214 EPI_ISL_1365139819.48OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0213 EPI_ISL_1365139722.85OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0212 EPI_ISL_1365139625.02OmicronBA.2.3++TP
GU0211 EPI_ISL_1365139517.89OmicronBA.5++TP
GU0210 EPI_ISL_1365139416.19OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0209 EPI_ISL_1365139317.39OmicronBA.2.3++TP
GU0208 EPI_ISL_1365139215.04OmicronBA.2.3++TP
GU0207 EPI_ISL_1365139121.9OmicronBA.5--FN
GU0206 EPI_ISL_1365139014.64OmicronBA.2.40.1++TP
GU0205 EPI_ISL_1365138921.57OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0204 EPI_ISL_1332964726.02OmicronBA.2.3++TP
GU0203 EPI_ISL_1332964620.91OmicronBA.2++TP
GU0197 EPI_ISL_1320301521.27OmicronBA.2++TP
GS0849 EPI_ISL_1190001424.76OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0851 EPI_ISL_1190001518.28OmicronBA.2++TP
GS0853 EPI_ISL_1190001617.88OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0861 EPI_ISL_1190001718.89OmicronBA.2++TP
GS0862 EPI_ISL_1190001821.14OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0863 EPI_ISL_1190001919.58OmicronBA.2++TP
GS0864 EPI_ISL_1190002015.86OmicronBA.2++TP
GS0865 EPI_ISL_1190002117.38OmicronBA.2++TP
GS0868 EPI_ISL_1190002219.29OmicronBA.1++TP
GS0871 EPI_ISL_1190002329.00OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0877 EPI_ISL_1190002420.66OmicronBA.2++TP
GS0881 EPI_ISL_1190002525.71OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0882 EPI_ISL_1190002625.84OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0883 EPI_ISL_1190002723.1OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0884 EPI_ISL_1190002821.13OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0887 EPI_ISL_1190002927.01OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0891 EPI_ISL_1190003026.48OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0892 EPI_ISL_1190003118.46OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0898 EPI_ISL_1190003222.72OmicronBA.1++TP
GS0917 EPI_ISL_1190004422.27OmicronBA.2++TP
GS0918 EPI_ISL_1190004517.68OmicronBA.2++TP
GS0919 EPI_ISL_1190004620.45OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0920 EPI_ISL_1190004721.72OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0921 EPI_ISL_1190004817.53OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0924 EPI_ISL_1190005012.6OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS1098 EPI_ISL_1320307623.65OmicronBA.2--FN
GS1099 EPI_ISL_1320307724.16OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS1100 EPI_ISL_1320307824.09OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS1101 EPI_ISL_1320307918.37OmicronBA.2++TP
GS1102 EPI_ISL_1320308025.02OmicronBA.1.1--FN
GS1103 EPI_ISL_1320308119.20OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS1104 EPI_ISL_1320308216.13OmicronBA.1.1--FN
GS1105 EPI_ISL_1320308315.91OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS1106 EPI_ISL_1320308420.40OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS1107 EPI_ISL_1320308524.21OmicronBA.1.1--FN
GS1108 EPI_ISL_1320308620.20OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS1109 EPI_ISL_1320308725.95OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS1110 EPI_ISL_1320308825.47OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS1111 EPI_ISL_1320298525.14OmicronBA.1.14++TP
GS1112 EPI_ISL_1320298620.50OmicronBA.2.10-+FN
GS1113 EPI_ISL_1320298718.70OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS1116 EPI_ISL_1320299019.46OmicronBA.1.1--FN
GS1117 EPI_ISL_1320299126.53OmicronBA.1++TP
GS1128 EPI_ISL_1320299918.16OmicronBA.1.15-+FN
GS1118 EPI_ISL_1320299225.88OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS1119 EPI_ISL_1320299325.17OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS1121 EPI_ISL_1320299417.92OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS1122 EPI_ISL_1320299525.50OmicronBA.1.1++TP
GS0677 EPI_ISL_1189993116.11DeltaAY.59--TN
GS0679 EPI_ISL_1189993315.74DeltaAY.59--TN
GS0681 EPI_ISL_1189993420.39DeltaAY.79--TN
GS0682 EPI_ISL_1189993524.49DeltaAY.79--TN
GS0683 EPI_ISL_1189993625.45DeltaAY.79--TN
GS0685 EPI_ISL_1189993820.08DeltaAY.75--TN
GS0686 EPI_ISL_1189993920.25DeltaAY.79--TN
GS0688 EPI_ISL_1189994022.91DeltaAY.59--TN
GS0689 EPI_ISL_1189994124.39DeltaAY.59--TN
GS0690 EPI_ISL_1189994227.62DeltaAY.59--TN
GS0691 EPI_ISL_1189994324.93DeltaAY.59--TN
GS0694 EPI_ISL_1189994521.38DeltaAY.23--TN
GS0695 EPI_ISL_1189994623.02DeltaAY.79--TN
GS0696 EPI_ISL_1189994721.25DeltaAY.59--TN
GS0697 EPI_ISL_1189994817.66DeltaAY.23--TN
GS0698 EPI_ISL_1189994920.02DeltaAY.59--TN
M001NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M002NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M003NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M004NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M005NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M006NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M007NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M008NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M009NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M010NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M011NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M012NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M013NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M014NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M015NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
M016NANDNon-COVID-19 samplesND--TN
XBB       
GU0399 EPI_ISL_1577598525.72XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0411 EPI_ISL_1577598219.37XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0412 EPI_ISL_1577598118.82XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0419NA21.11XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0420NA26.70XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0425NA16.03XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0426NA19.35XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0428NA22.97XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0429NA23.52XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0431NA20.21XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0434NA21.10XBBXBB.2++TP
GU0435NA26.45XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0436NA20.03XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0438NA27.15XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0439NA20.12XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0444NA20.24XBBXBB.1--FN
GU0445NA17.70XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0461NA17.54XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0484NA20.63XBBXBB.2++TP
GU0486NA21.50XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0488NA18.33XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0489NA16.68XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0502NA18.65XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0503NA19.48XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0504NA23.40XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0507NA22.03XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0511NA22.29XBBXBB.1.1++TP
GU0518NA19.06XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0540NA17.91XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0547NA15.49XBBXBB.1.1++TP
GU0557NA18.30XBBXBB++TP
GU0566NA17.15XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0568NA20.48XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0494NA15.81XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0496NA20.46XBBXBB++TP
GU0601 EPI_ISL_1660961923.12XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0609 EPI_ISL_1660962415.62XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0610 EPI_ISL_1660962525.16XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0611 EPI_ISL_1660962620.24XBBXBB.1--FN
GU0612 EPI_ISL_1660962719.19XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0613 EPI_ISL_1660962817.38XBBXBB++TP
GU0618 EPI_ISL_1660963321.20XBBXBB++TP
GU0620 EPI_ISL_1660963423.17XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0625 EPI_ISL_1660963921.42XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0626 EPI_ISL_1660964023.31XBBXBB.1.1++TP
GU0632 EPI_ISL_1660964623.10XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0635 EPI_ISL_1660964925.97XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0636 EPI_ISL_1660965026.25XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0639 EPI_ISL_1660965320.27XBBXBB.1--FN
GU0641 EPI_ISL_1660965522.62XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0648NA27.21XBBXBB.2++TP
GU0652 EPI_ISL_1660965820.12XBBXBB.1--FN
GU0656 EPI_ISL_1660966217.80XBBXBB.1.1++TP
GU0659 EPI_ISL_1660966415.80XBBXBB.1--FN
GU0660 EPI_ISL_1660966524.32XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0661 EPI_ISL_1660966624.93XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0590NA24.20XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0585NA21.50XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0583NA22.06XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0570NA26.10XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0571NA25.92XBBXBB.1++TP
GU0137 EPI_ISL_1365137817.24OmicronBA.2--TN
GU0136 EPI_ISL_1365137717.13OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GU0135 EPI_ISL_1365137626.75OmicronBA.2--TN
GU0133 EPI_ISL_1365137419.09OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GU0134 EPI_ISL_1365137526.51OmicronBA.2.10--TN
GU0131 EPI_ISL_1365137220.32OmicronBA.2.3--TN
GU0132 EPI_ISL_1365137324.9OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GU0130 EPI_ISL_1365137123.61OmicronBA.2.3--TN
GU0196 EPI_ISL_1320301416.66OmicronBA.2--TN
GU0197 EPI_ISL_1320301521.27OmicronBA.2--TN
GU0195 EPI_ISL_1320301315.06OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GU0194 EPI_ISL_1320301213.17OmicronBA.2--TN
GU0193 EPI_ISL_1320301114.28OmicronBA.2--TN
GU0192 EPI_ISL_1421773823.17OmicronBA.2--TN
GU0186 EPI_ISL_1421773217.12OmicronBA.2--TN
GU0181 EPI_ISL_1421772724.85OmicronBA.2--TN
GU0179 EPI_ISL_1227717620.86OmicronBA.2--TN
GU0180 EPI_ISL_1421772619.10OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GU0178 EPI_ISL_1227717517.42OmicronBA.2.9--TN
GU0189 EPI_ISL_1421773517.27OmicronBA.2.3--TN
GU0188 EPI_ISL_1421773423.90OmicronBA.2.3--TN
GU0187 EPI_ISL_1421773321.01OmicronBA.2.40.1--TN
GU0185 EPI_ISL_1421773124.48OmicronBA.2--TN
GU0184 EPI_ISL_1421773025.79OmicronBA.2.3--TN
GU0183 EPI_ISL_1421772919.69OmicronBA.2--TN
GU0042 EPI_ISL_1421772525.22OmicronBA.2.3--TN
GU0041 EPI_ISL_1421772420.13OmicronBA.2.3--TN
GS1123 EPI_ISL_1320299617.25OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1125 EPI_ISL_1320299726.27OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1126 EPI_ISL_1320299817.22OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1129 EPI_ISL_1320300018.64OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1130 EPI_ISL_1320300117.11OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1118 EPI_ISL_1320299226.00OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1131 EPI_ISL_1320300225.89OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1122 EPI_ISL_1320299518.68OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS0868 EPI_ISL_1190002216.65OmicronBA.1--TN
GS1119 EPI_ISL_1320299319.23OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1121 EPI_ISL_1320299416.06OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1128 EPI_ISL_1320299924.34OmicronBA.1.15--TN
GS1117 EPI_ISL_1320299123.68OmicronBA.1--TN
GS1112 EPI_ISL_1320298626.02OmicronBA.2.10--TN
GS1113 EPI_ISL_1320298720.47OmicronBA.1.1--TN
GS1111 EPI_ISL_1320298523.80OmicronBA.1.14--TN
GS1008 EPI_ISL_1197620922.78OmicronBA.1.1-+FP
GS1022 EPI_ISL_1227712924.54OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS1015 EPI_ISL_1197621518.12OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS1018 EPI_ISL_1197621625.06OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS1020 EPI_ISL_1197621721.37OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS1021 EPI_ISL_1197621825.20OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS1024 EPI_ISL_1227713025.74OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS1028 EPI_ISL_1227713424.14OmicronBA.1.1++FP
GS1029 EPI_ISL_1227713518.72OmicronBA.2.10++FP
GS0987 EPI_ISL_1197619622.39OmicronBA.1++FP
GS1030 EPI_ISL_1227713622.60OmicronBA.2.10++FP
GS1031 EPI_ISL_1227713723.79OmicronBA.2.10++FP
GS1032 EPI_ISL_1227713825.53OmicronBA.2.10++FP
GS1033 EPI_ISL_1227713917.87OmicronBA.2.10--TN
GS1042 EPI_ISL_1227714618.87OmicronBA.2.10+-FP
GS1041 EPI_ISL_1227714518.52OmicronBA.2.10++FP
GS1039 EPI_ISL_1227714323.28OmicronBA.2.10++FP
GS1037 EPI_ISL_1227714222.93OmicronBA.2.10++FP
GS0988 EPI_ISL_1197619720.09OmicronBA.1-+FP
GS1036 EPI_ISL1227714120.00OmicronBA.2.10++FP

[i] aSample identification code based on the list provided by the Advanced Genomic and Bioinformatic Laboratory;

[ii] bGISAID ID refers to unique identifier generated by GISAID for each sequence deposition;

[iii] cthe Ct column corresponds to the quantification cycle of the sample positive for SARS-CoV-2 using the 2019nCoV primer kit;

[iv] dresults of sequencing obtained in the GISAID EpiCoV platform;

[v] eresults of RT-LAMP assay in duplicate;

[vi] foutcome of the RT-LAMP assay. Ct, cycle threshold; -, negative result (no color change); +, positive result (color change); NA, not applicable (NA for COVID-19 samples refers to an entry rejected by GISAID due to poor quality); ND, not detected; TP, true positive; TN, true negative; FP, false positive; FN, false negative; RT-LAMP, reverse-transcription loop-mediated isothermal amplification; SARS-CoV-2, severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2.

The clinical performance of the Delta-, Omicron- and XBB-specific primer sets is summarized in Table III. Omicron-specific LAMP primers performed exhibited the optimal performance, with a sensitivity of 89.47%, specificity of 100% and an accuracy of 92.18%. The Delta-specific LAMP primers had the highest sensitivity of 100%, but with a very low specificity of 43.75% and a final accuracy of 71.57%. The XBB-specific LAMP primers scored a sensitivity of 91.80%, a specificity of 69.84% and an accuracy of 80.64%.

Table III

Summary of the RT-LAMP clinical results.

Table III

Summary of the RT-LAMP clinical results.

 PerformanceNo. of samples
SARS-CoV-2 variantSensitivity (%)Specificity (%)Accuracy (%)PositiveNegativeTotal
Delta10043.7571.57474895
Omicron89.4710092.189533128
XBB91.8069.8480.646163124

[i] All Delta, Omicron and XBB were confirmed positive by sequencing.

Discussion

Throughout the pandemic, SARS-CoV-2 has been evolving through mutations in its genetic code. These mutations can endow the virus certain advantages, such as spreading more easily or evading our immune defenses (2). Variants with these beneficial mutations, known as VOCs tend to become more prevalent in the population. To remain ahead of the virus, it is crucial to track new variants with the potential to spread rapidly. WGS is a powerful tool for identifying these new variants. However, researchers have also discovered specific mutations that are unique to each VOC. These unique mutations function as a fingerprint, allowing scientists to identify the variant without needing full genetic sequencing.

The geographical distribution of SARS-CoV-2 variants has been uneven, with some regions experiencing rapid and successive waves of different variants, while others have had less data due to limited sequencing. The Delta variant was particularly widespread, predominating in Africa, Asia, Europe, North America and Oceania by July, 2021(9). In South America, the Gamma variant remained dominant for a time, before being overtaken by the Delta variant. The emergence of the Omicron variant then rapidly shifted the global landscape again. However, the detection and tracking of these variants has been heavily influenced by sequencing capacity, with countries such as the United Kingdom having higher sequencing coverage compared to countries such as Brazil, where the sequencing of positive cases is markedly lower (8). This discrepancy in genomic surveillance highlights the challenge of monitoring variants in real-time.

The lack of sequencing capacity in a number of low- and middle-income countries creates a significant gap in the understanding of variant spread and evolution (10). This limitation means that data from these regions may be underrepresented in global databases, such as GISAID, potentially leading to an incomplete picture of global variant dynamics (9). The uneven distribution of sequencing capacity also means that some countries may experience surges in cases due to a variant, but have limited ability to understand which variant is responsible. There is a need for more accessible and affordable methods for variant detection, such as RT-LAMP, to be deployed in these regions to complement limited sequencing capacity and to help ensure effective public health responses and control measures.

While some recent research has focused on using RT-LAMP to detect all SARS-CoV-2 variants regardless of strain (11,12), this approach offers limited value for tracking specific variants in epidemiological studies. However, RT-LAMP has exhibited promise in identifying specific variants. For example, Sherril-Mix et al (13) developed a method using molecular beacons to detect the Alpha variant (B.1.1.7) by targeting the S1Δ69-70 deletion in its genome. Another study by Yang et al (14) presented an RT-LAMP genotyping method that specifically identifies Delta variants by analyzing the R203M mutation in the N gene. This method achieved high accuracy without requiring additional probes, but relied on calculating the Ct ratio between results from two separate reactions per sample. Building on this progress, dos Santos et al (8) proposed a concept for an RT-LAMP assay targeting mutations C21614T (S:L18F) and C21638T (S:P26S) specific to Gamma variants and their descendants. This method avoids complex equipment and additional probes often required in conventional quantitative LAMP protocols. The present study aimed to take this a step further by introducing specific primer sets designed to detect the Delta, Omicron and XBB variants based on their unique mutations (S: L452R, S: T478K, S: E452A and A19326G).

In the present study, a total of 23 sets of LAMP primes were designed and screened for their performance against targeted SARS-CoV-2 variants (i.e. Delta, Omicron and XBB). Only three sets of LAMP primers exhibited promising performance against its target (Table I). This suggests a limited capability of openly available software tools (i.e., PrimerExplorerV5) and a poor understanding in LAMP primer design. One should be prepared to design and screen a handful of LAMP primers to increase the chances of obtaining a few useable candidates. A notable contribution of the present study is that it describes novel RT-LAMP primers that can distinguish between COVID-19 samples carrying mutations specific to the VOCs, Delta, Omicron and XBB (and its descendants). These mutations function as markers for identifying these VOCs with an accuracy of 71 to 92% in samples with a Ct value ≤25). Notably, the assay even performs well for samples with a Ct value as high as 30. This accuracy is comparable to that reported by dos Santos et al (8) (91.11%), highlighting the potential of these primers for SARS-CoV-2 lineage detection.

The recent study by Alhamid et al (15) demonstrated an optimal LAMP performance on SARS-CoV-2 detection by removing outer primer (i.e., LF) in the LAMP reaction. This five-primer LAMP assay avoids misamplification for up to 120 min, thus significantly preventing false positive results. Coincidently, primer set LRTK (Table I) in the present study is also a five-primer LAMP system. Outer primer LF was not suggested by PrimerExplorerV5 for primer set LRTK due to the low scoring of LF candidates. Nevertheless, primer set LRTK was tested and exhibited a good performance against the Delta variant detection. However, LAMP reaction using primer set LRTK was not performed and its misamplification ability was not determined. While the study by Alhamid et al (15) and the present study demonstrated the practicality of five-primer LAMP reaction, further studies need to be performed on different target locations (for the same gene) and different genes to prove its usefulness.

The RT-LAMP assay is proving useful for monitoring emerging disease variants. It offers sensitivity comparable to traditional sequencing, the current gold standard. In the present study, RT-LAMP successfully distinguished the majority of samples with a Ct value ≤25, with some Ct values reaching 30. Sequencing functions best with samples that have lower Ct values as they provide more genetic material, leading to more accurate variant identification. This suggests that the RT-LAMP assay from the present study could be a valuable screening tool in areas with limited sequencing capabilities.

A key advantage of RT-LAMP for variant identification is its speed and affordability compared to other techniques. It has been demonstrated that RT-LAMP costs significantly less per sample, at least 50-fold more economical than next-generation sequencing (NGS) and 4.6-fold more economical than RT-qPCR (8). Furthermore, RT-LAMP boasts a more rapid turnaround time, with results available in 30 min to 1 h. This is a notable improvement over RT-qPCR, which typically takes at least 2 h, and NGS, which can take up to 1 or 2 days. These attributes render RT-LAMP a promising tool for rapid diagnosis and VOC surveillance.

With vaccinations rising globally, keeping track of new variants is crucial. This helps policymakers make informed decisions and prevent outbreaks from highly transmissible or antibody-evading variants, such as Omicron. The present study highlights how a special type of RT-LAMP test, designed to target specific lineages, can be a valuable tool. It allows researchers to estimate how common these lineages are within a population during a specific week. This test could be particularly useful in areas where sequencing resources are limited or expensive. It can act as a preliminary screening method before resorting to more in-depth sequencing techniques.

There are two main ways to improve these assays: Exploring enzymes better suited for displacing existing strands and creating cost-effective, in-house reagents. In fact, a previous study was conducted to evaluate the usefulness of freeze-dried (lyophilized) RT-LAMP reagents as at-home self-testing kit (5). The authors of that study demonstrated that lyophilized RT-LAMP reactions had fewer false positives compared to those using liquid reagents. This technique offers several advantages: An extended shelf life, room-temperature storage and the elimination of cold-chain shipping costs (5).

While RT-LAMP offers significant advantages for SARS-CoV-2 detection, it is essential to acknowledge its limitations. One notable concern is the risk of false positive results, which can arise from non-specific amplification, especially when using colorimetric detection (15). Suboptimal primer design can also lead to misamplification (16). Additionally, sample quality can impact assay performance. In particular, the presence of inhibitors in crude samples such as saliva, blood, and urine can affect the accuracy of the test (12). Some studies have found that RT-LAMP becomes less reliable for samples with high cycle quantification values (Cq) on RT-qPCR. Moreover, visual interpretation of colorimetric results can introduce user errors, and extended storage at elevated temperatures can reduce the colour contrast, increasing misinterpretations (5). Despite these limitations, the ongoing optimization of RT-LAMP assays aims to reduce these issues. For example, the use of five primers instead of six can reduce the false positive rate (15).

Integrating RT-LAMP into current COVID-19 testing strategies, particularly in low-resource settings, requires a strategic approach. Due to its low cost and simplicity, RT-LAMP can be used as a screening tool to identify potentially positive cases. Positive results can then be confirmed using a more accurate test like RT-qPCR, if resources allow. The rapid turn-around time of RT-LAMP makes it valuable for mass surveillance, and this is particularly important for identifying the virus earlier in the transmissible phase. RT-LAMP assays that utilize a simple workflow and minimal equipment are ideal for use in decentralized settings, such as local pharmacies, mobile labs or in the home. In these situations, a technician or the patient themselves would take the sample using a swab and then return the sample for testing. Furthermore, the capacity of RT-LAMP assays to detect variants using specific primers makes it useful for monitoring emerging variants. Overall, the trade-offs between speed, cost and accuracy should be considered when deploying RT-LAMP as a complementary tool to existing methods, particularly in low resource settings.

In conclusion, these novel SARS-CoV-2 variant detection methods are innovative. At under $5 per test (excluding labor and processing), they are significantly more cost-effective than existing options. In addition, they can be easily scaled up or down to fit the needs of any setting, from small workplaces with a handful of employees to schools with a few thousand students. The simple equipment needed and the low cost render them ideal for areas with limited resources, which have often been hit hardest by the pandemic.

Acknowledgements

Not applicable.

Funding

Funding: The present study was funded by the Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation (MOSTI) Malaysia under the research grant Strategic Research Fund (SRF) Project no. SRF08211166APP.

Availability of data and materials

The DNA sequencing data for the SARS-CoV-2 variants tested in the present study may be found in the GISAID repository at www.gisaid.org using the respective GISAID IDs outlined in Table II. The user may view and/or download information using the respective GISAID IDs at the GISAID database. First, the user needs to register an account and log in to GISAID at www.gisaid.org. Upon logging in, the user can click on the ‘EpiCoV’ database and enter the EPI_ISL ID into the search tool. Information regarding the entry will be available in a new window.

Authors' contributions

All authors (KOL, NMI, AA and NAJ) contributed to the conception and design of the study. Genome analysis and alignment was performed by AA. The SARS-CoV-2 RNA samples were prepared by NMI and NAJ. The LAMP primer design and LAMP assay were performed by NMI and KOL. NMI and KOL confirm the authenticity of all the raw data. The first draft of the manuscript was written by KOL and all authors commented on previous versions of the manuscript. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

The National Institutes of Biotechnology Malaysia confirmed that no ethics approval or patient consent were required for the present study due to the following reasons: The study was conducted as part of a government-funded initiative during the COVID-19 pandemic, which prioritized rapid response to public health needs. The samples used for the project were provided by government hospitals specifically for surveillance and sequencing purposes, in alignment with national public health objectives. Under such circumstances, the project fell within the scope of public health surveillance, which is often exempt from individual consent requirements. Additionally, the study adhered to strict data protection protocols, ensuring that all samples were anonymized and used solely for the purpose of developing diagnostic methods to combat the pandemic.

Patient consent for publication

Not applicable.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

References

1 

Konings F, Perkins MD, Kuhn JH, Pallen MJ, Alm EJ, Archer BN, Barakat A, Bedford T, Bhiman JN, Caly L, et al: SARS-CoV-2 Variants of Interest and Concern naming scheme conducive for global discourse. Nat Microbiol. 6:821–823. 2021.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

2 

Saito A, Irie T, Suzuki R, Maemura T, Nasser H, Uriu K, Kosugi Y, Shirakawa K, Sadamasu K, Kimura I, et al: Enhanced fusogenicity and pathogenicity of SARS-CoV-2 Delta P681R mutation. Nature. 602:300–306. 2022.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

3 

Vega-Magaña N, Sánchez-Sánchez R, Hernández-Bello J, Venancio-Landeros AA, Peña-Rodríguez M, Vega-Zepeda RA, Galindo-Ornelas B, Díaz-Sánchez M, García-Chagollán M, Macedo-Ojeda G, et al: RT-qPCR assays for rapid detection of the N501Y, 69-70del, K417N, and E484K SARS-CoV-2 mutations: A screening strategy to identify variants with clinical impact. Front Cell Infect Microbiol. 11(672562)2021.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

4 

Sagar V, Singh MP, Kaur G, Khurana R, Agarwal R, Ratho RK, Ghosh A, Kulashri A and Aggarwal AK: LAMP-Based Point-of-Care nucleic Acid-based detection method can be useful for quick Decision-making for diagnosis of acute COVID-19 Emergency cases in Hospital Settings. COVID. 3:914–923. 2023.

5 

Song X, Coulter FJ, Yang M, Smith JL, Tafesse FG, Messer WB and Reif JH: A lyophilized colorimetric RT-LAMP test kit for rapid, low-cost, at-home molecular testing of SARS-CoV-2 and other pathogens. Sci Rep. 12(7043)2022.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

6 

Notomi T, Okayama H, Masubuchi H, Yonekawa T, Watanabe K, Amino N and Hase T: Loop-mediated isothermal amplification of DNA. Nucleic Acids Res. 28(E63)2000.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

7 

Nagamine K, Hase T and Notomi T: Accelerated reaction by Loop-mediated isothermal amplification using loop primers. Mol Cell Probes. 16:223–229. 2002.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

8 

Dos Santos CA, Silva LDC, Souza Júnior MN, Mendes GM, Estrela PFN, de Oliveira KG, de Curcio JS, Resende PC, Siqueira MM, Pauvolid-Corrêa A, et al: Detecting lineage-defining mutations in SARS-CoV-2 using colorimetric RT-LAMP without probes or additional primers. Sci Rep. 12(11500)2022.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

9 

Chan WS, Lam YM, Law JHY, Chan TL, Ma ESK and Tang BSF: Geographical prevalence of SARS-CoV-2 variants, August 2020 to July 2021. Sci Rep. 12(4704)2022.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

10 

Chen Z, Azman AS, Chen X, Zou J, Tian Y, Sun R, Xu X, Wu Y, Lu W, Ge S, et al: Global landscape of SARS-CoV-2 genomic surveillance and data sharing. Nat Genet. 54:499–507. 2022.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

11 

Luo Z, Ye C, Xiao H, Yin J, Liang Y, Ruan Z, Luo D, Gao D, Tan Q, Li Y, et al: Optimization of loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) assay for robust visualization in SARS-CoV-2 and emerging variants diagnosis. Chem Eng Sci. 251(117430)2022.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

12 

Alves PA, de Oliveira EG, Franco-Luiz APM, Almeida LT, Gonçalves AB, Borges IA, Rocha FS, Rocha RP, Bezerra MF, Miranda P, et al: Optimization and clinical validation of colorimetric reverse transcription loop-mediated isothermal amplification, a fast, highly sensitive and specific COVID-19 molecular diagnostic tool that is robust to Detect SARS-CoV-2 variants of concern. Front Microbiol. 12(713713)2021.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

13 

Sherrill-Mix S, Van Duyne GD and Bushman FD: Molecular beacons allow specific RT-LAMP detection of B.1.1.7 variant SARS-CoV-2. J Biomol Tech. 32:98–101. 2021.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

14 

Yang J, Hu X, Wang W, Yang Y, Zhang X, Fang W, Zhang L, Li S and Gu B: RT-LAMP assay for rapid detection of the R203M mutation in SARS-CoV-2 Delta variant. Emerg Microbes Infect. 11:978–987. 2022.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

15 

Alhamid G, Tombuloglu H and Al-Suhaimi E: Development of loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) assays using five primers reduces the false-positive rate in COVID-19 diagnosis. Sci Rep. 13(5066)2023.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

16 

Nawab M, Riaz SK, Ismail E, Ahamed A, Tariq A, Malik MFA, Qusty NF, Bantun F, Slama P, Umair M, et al: Integrated approach for detection of SARS-CoV-2 and its variant by utilizing LAMP and ARMS-PCR. Ann Clin Microbiol Antimicrob. 23(11)2024.PubMed/NCBI View Article : Google Scholar

Related Articles

Journal Cover

July-August 2025
Volume 7 Issue 4

Print ISSN: 2632-2900
Online ISSN:2632-2919

Sign up for eToc alerts

Recommend to Library

Copy and paste a formatted citation
x
Spandidos Publications style
Low K, Md Iqbal N, Ahmad A and Johari N: Detection of SARS‑CoV‑2 Delta, Omicron and XBB variant using colorimetric reverse‑transcription loop‑mediated isothermal amplification and specific primers. World Acad Sci J 7: 50, 2025.
APA
Low, K., Md Iqbal, N., Ahmad, A., & Johari, N. (2025). Detection of SARS‑CoV‑2 Delta, Omicron and XBB variant using colorimetric reverse‑transcription loop‑mediated isothermal amplification and specific primers. World Academy of Sciences Journal, 7, 50. https://doi.org/10.3892/wasj.2025.338
MLA
Low, K., Md Iqbal, N., Ahmad, A., Johari, N."Detection of SARS‑CoV‑2 Delta, Omicron and XBB variant using colorimetric reverse‑transcription loop‑mediated isothermal amplification and specific primers". World Academy of Sciences Journal 7.4 (2025): 50.
Chicago
Low, K., Md Iqbal, N., Ahmad, A., Johari, N."Detection of SARS‑CoV‑2 Delta, Omicron and XBB variant using colorimetric reverse‑transcription loop‑mediated isothermal amplification and specific primers". World Academy of Sciences Journal 7, no. 4 (2025): 50. https://doi.org/10.3892/wasj.2025.338
a