The implementation of monoclonal antibody therapeutics during the COVID-19 pandemic altered the selective pressures encountered by SARS-CoV-2, raising the possibility of selection for resistant variants. Within-host viral evolution was reported in treated immunocompromised individuals but whether this signifies a real risk of onward transmission is unclear. We used a regional SARS-CoV-2 sequencing program to monitor lineages with clinically relevant variants in identified patients, which facilitated analysis of parameters potentially relevant to new variant emergence. Here we describe a newly acquired spike E484K mutation detected within the B.1.311 lineage. Multiple individuals in 2 households of the same extended family were infected. The timing and patterns of spread were consistent with de novo emergence of this E484K variant in the bamlanivimab-treated index patient. Our study suggests that the selective pressures introduced by the widespread administration of these antibodies may warrant increased genomic surveillance to identify and mitigate spread of therapy-induced variants.